Nothing like presenting a green technologies conference with a
renewable energy focus on a day when oil prices skyrocket to new highs,
the Dow Jones stock average takes a nearly 400-point hit, and the US
Senate shoots down the Climate Security Act. As the news cycle would
have it, the timing of the
GreenTech 2008 event held last Friday (June 6) in Pasadena, CA, could not have been much more compelling.
Cohosted by local nonprofit entrepreneur empowerers
Entretech and ecofriendly catalytic chemical company
Materia,
the daylong symposium featured speakers from the cleantech wing of the
venture capital community, utility companies, and a wide-ranging
(though not all-inclusive) selection of solar PV, water purification,
nuclear, wind, biofuel, and green design representatives.
Some might quibble with the lineup, in terms of what kind of
companies were or were not included. The presence of two presenters
from what Materia's Mike Giardello euphemistically called the "energy
from fission" area might have rankled certain greener-than-thou types
who seek to keep the nuke option out of the renewable discussion.
But I found the presentations by Phillip Finck of the Global Nuclear Energy Partnership (GNEP) and
Idaho National Lab
and especially that of Joe Reyes, CTO of NuScale Power (developer of
small-scale "modular nuclear power generation technology"), to be quite
interesting and informative. Although waste disposal remains a
sensitive topic, the two true believers made a strong case that new and
next-gen nuke plants (such as thorium-based reactors) will play an
important role in the planetary move away from carbon-based energy
dependency. Just ask the French, who rely on nuclear for some 80% of
their power-grid needs and have made big strides in improving the
technologies.
For an event with the subtheme of "Rethinking energy," I was struck
by the absence of any speaker from the emergent thin-film/new-tech
battery or energy scavenging/harvesting sectors (although I did chat
with attendee Rachid Yazami, who's starting up a new, Southern
California-based lithium-ion energy-storage player,
CFX Battery).
A talk from a tide- and wavepower energy startup would have also been
welcome, especially given the relative proximity of the conference to
the planet's largest source of that renewable--the Pacific Ocean.
Many of the companies and presenters had either direct or indirect
ties to the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA) and
especially the California Institute of Technology/Jet Propulsion Lab
(Caltech/JPL). Fred Farina of Caltech's tech transfer office said 80
companies have spun out of the institute, at an average of eight per
year. Of those that have emerged from the institute so far, 75% are
either ongoing startup concerns or have successfully gone public or
been acquired by a larger company--a pretty impressive success rate.
Solarmer Energy's plastic PV cell technology has UCLA beginnings, while much of the technical team helping
Soliant Energy develop
and productize its concentrating PV modules came from JPL. Caltech
research on branched nanopolymers, and nano- and microparticles with
tunable capture sites led to AquaNano Technologies' new
water-purification membrane approach, while the three cofounders of
Gevo brought their biofuels breakthroughs (can you say, butanol?) with them from the brainy Pasadena campus as well.
One recurring theme that cut across several of the presentations is
that new green techs must be scalable and take advantage of the
infrastructure that's already in place. Gevo's Pat Gruber spoke of the
importance of "designing technologies to fit into the capital base of
existing facilities," citing gas pipelines and beer plants as examples
where biofuels could also flow or be produced.
Elevance Renewable Sciences'
Mel Luetkens talked about the concept of "retrofittable assets," where
you don't start "from scratch" and utilize "existing assets" for
products such as his company's metathesis-enabled renewable biochem
feedstocks.
Jeff Green of
Nano H20 explained
that his UCLA-rooted startup's reverse-osmosis nanocomposite membranes
will be able to use, with minor tweaking, the same manufacturing
process as more traditional membranes do and "can retrofit into
existing desalination plants when ready." AquaNano's membrane can also
be "easily integrated into existing water treatment systems," according
to the company's Mamadou Diallo.
Soliant's Art Buckland noted the risk-minimizing importance of
"using established solar channels, field-proven materials, components,
and subsystems," and established "contract manufacturing" in the
company's efforts to bring its easy-to-install, very-high-efficiency
CPV modules to the commercial rooftop market. Paul Glenney of
AeroVironment's Clean Energy Tech Center
said that the company's "small wind turbines for the built environment"
had to be "modular, scalable, and quick to install," and were
"complimentary to PV" and could be "utility-grid connected."
Glenney's notion of different renewables being "complimentary"
touches on another core green-and-clean truth: no single solution will
provide a silver bullet for the globe's growing energy crisis and
carbon-fed eco-mess. Using a combination of green-energy sources to
power a biofuel plant, instead of relying entirely on electricity from
a coal-powered grid, or deploying a PV fab's own panels along with a
few wind turbines to help keep the lights on and tools running on the
factory floor represent the kind of models that industrial mavens need
to embrace in the new economy. Information-sharing forums like the
GreenTech conference play a key role in shaping the discussion moving
forward.