What rabbit will First Solar pull out of the hat?

  • one financial analyst believes First Solar will have to pull a rabbit out of its hat if the financial markets are going to react positively
    One financial analyst believes First Solar will have to pull a rabbit out of its hat if the financial markets are going to react positively to guidance.

Blogger

Mark Osborne
Mark Osborne
Mark Osborne is currently the Senior News Editor for Photovoltaics International and PV-Tech website. He has launched multiple technology titles in print and online covering manufacturing in the automotive, shipping, semiconductor and solar sectors in a publishing career spanning three decades. Mark started blogging in 2005, the first technology editor to do so and has worked online since 1996. A veteran manufacturing technology journalist and editor, Mark has been responsible for a series of innovative formats for delivering technical content to an engineering-based audience.

Update (2): First Solar is holding a conference call tomorrow (Wednesday, December 14, 8:00am EST) to provide financial guidance for 2012. As we noted recently, the CdTe thin-film leader is set to be the first of any major PV manufacturer to give guidance for next year, after what can only be described as a ‘challenging’ year for the whole industry.

With module prices set to continue to decline, though not at the same rate next year, the industry faces a multitude of issues so the call tomorrow could set the scene for much of the industry.

Moreover, there is a good chance First Solar could regain the industry’s number one spot again, having already guided 2011 revenue to be in the range of US$3.0 billion to US$3.3 billion.

The 2010 leader and nearest rival in the revenue stakes, Suntech has already guided 2011 revenue of between US$3.0-US$3.1 billion, adding to the interest in First Solar’s guidance call.

However, First Solar is facing a tough time competing with falling c-Si module prices and the collapse of polysilicon prices that have yet to fully permeate through to product production costs and therefore lower product prices.

Though having been cushioned by its massive multi-gigawatt project pipeline, financing problems have emerged once again, especially in Europe. FiT changes have also shifted markets in Europe towards rooftop and that hasn’t been one of First Solar’s strengths having lower module efficiency levels than either CIGS thin film technologies and conventional crystalline silicon offerings.

Though much of the current utility-scale business in US focused and First Solar leads the pack in that respect, China is ramping-up ground-mounted projects and that is a market the company wants to be a major player in but has yet to secure a foothold.

With 2012 industry dynamics difficult to gauge, other than perhaps it could be worse than this year has proved to be; one financial analyst believes First Solar will have to pull a rabbit out of its hat if the financial markets are going to react positively to guidance.

According to Jesse Pichel at Jeffries, First Solar may need two rabbits!

The financial analyst thinks that if First Solar announces the introduction of a high-efficiency CIGS thin-film module it would signify the company could better compete in the rooftop market going forward.

Though it’s the worst kept secret that First Solar has been developing CIGS technology the company has yet to make any public statement on the subject.

Should a CIGS module roadmap not be on the agenda tomorrow, Pichel is looking for an announcement about adding crystalline modules to its product portfolio, again to address the rooftop market.

Such is the concern for another challenging year, no rabbit from the hat and First Solar stock price will remain as depressed as the market.

We have less than 24 hours to find out. 

Update
 
In perhaps what could be a rather ironic development, The Wall Street Journal broke news that Markus Beck, a senior member of First Solar’s R&D team and well known for his CIGS cell technology work in the earlier days of Solyndra has left the company. 
 
According to the WSJ report, other members of his team in the CIGS development centre in Santa Clara have also left the company. WSJ cited a ‘person familiar with the situation,’ as no official statement had been announced. 
 
The report suggests that First Solar was narrowing-down its R&D focus in the tough financial conditions. 
 
This development could mean that its CIGS development efforts are over and that the company could be shifting work to pilot line, though the suggestion in the WSJ report that CIGS R&D was being scaled down or closed completely is also a valid assumption. 
 
Update 2. 
 
During the 2012 guidance call, First Solar management were asked in the Q&A session with financial analysts about the validity of the WSJ story. Management noted in response that its R&D spending forecast would be reduced and that it would have been substantially higher otherwise. 
 
Management noted that if they hadn’t made changes to R&D efforts, then costs would have risen significantly. 
 
The impression given was that its CIGS development efforts to date did not give management confidence that it could compete effectively with other CIGS manufacturers such as Solar Frontier in Japan, which had higher module efficiencies and manufacturing scale to offer strong competition in the future when First Solar would be vulnerable to pricing pressure on ramping and improving yields and efficiencies. 
 
Overall, the conference call produced no rabbits from the hat. 

 

Latest Comments

  • see-dub05 January 2012

    LJ,
    “Strong Buy”?  More like strong bye, bye.

    FSLR lost it’s way, expanding mfg w/o realizing that project development is a long, complicated process that can seldom be scheduled.

  • LJ13 December 2011

    New projects to be announced tomorrow!?!   

    “Strong Buy” they’ll probably announce new projects in tomorrow’s call, since all of their previous 4 projects are now SOLD!!! YES SOLD!!!! First Solar will build, operate and maintain the facilities!! They will need to HIRE more people to construct these farms!! Timeline of sales:

    August 5th, 2011: NRG Energy Acquires 290-Megawatt Agua Caliente Solar Project from First Solar.

    September 30th, 2011: Exelon Corp. announced its acquisition of Antelope Valley Solar Ranch One, a 230-megawatt solar photovoltaic project under development in northern Los Angeles County, Calif., from First Solar.

    October 7, 2011: GE EFS and NextEra buy First Solar’s 550-Megawatt Desert Sunlight Solar Farm.

    December 7th, 2011: First Solar Sells 550-megawatt California “Topaz” Solar Farm To MidAmerican Energy.

    The sale of “Topaz” is contingent on tying off “certain closing conditions” including permit and electrical interconnection arrangements… once confirmed (maybe during tomorrow’s call), stock will pop again, and shorts will get CRUSHED!!!

    These RECENT deals have broader implications, as it highlights that high quality projects will get financing even in a dislocated macro environment that has hampered project financing, and will have a positive perception effect!!!! They will announce more projects and when they do, the stock will pop… people will buy these farms!!!

    Strong Buy!!

  • LJ13 December 2011

Post a Comment

Post

Newsletter

Preview Latest Subscribe
We won't share your details - promise!

Publications

  • Photovoltaics International 14th Edition

    Photovoltaics International 14th Edition

    Published in November 2011, the 14th edition of Photovoltaics International provides a variety of technical papers from some of the industry’s stalwarts. Features include: TÜV Rheinland on junction box testing; Laser Zentrum Hannover on laser edge isolation of mc-Si cells; Calisolar on the importance of traceability; Fraunhofer ISE on EWT cells; and EPIA on Europe’s LCOE.

  • Photovoltaics International Lite, Volume 05 - 2011

    Photovoltaics International Lite, Volume 05 - 2011

    This digital interactive Lite sees Tom Cheyney follow Agua Caliente’s progress on becoming one of first truly utility-scale PV power farms, where 40–50MW (AC) will be commissioned by the end of the year. We also feature one of the world’s largest silicon thin-film PV power plants, Avenal; a report on warnings of the collapse of module prices from Solarbuzz and PI-Berlin presents tips on PV module testing. A print version of this edition will be distributed at Solar Power International 2011 in Dallas, Texas.

  • Manufacturing The Solar Future: The 2011 Production Annual

    Manufacturing The Solar Future: The 2011 Production Annual

    Manufacturing the Solar Future is the primary source guide for detailed information on the PV production process. This annual provides technical details on how the leading companies and research organizations worldwide are addressing this need by dramatically improving their manufacturing processes.

Partners

Acknowledgements

Solar Media