Misstatements by bill author influence vote to end Indiana net metering

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email
Inaccurate statements by Brandt Hershman reportedly influenced lawmakers to back the proposal, by asserting the bill offered the only remedy to a total wipeout of incentives for residential solar. Source: The statehousefile

The author of SB 309 – a bill that would effectively end retail net metering in Indiana – may have wrongly influenced other lawmakers to vote for the bill under false information.

Senator Brandt Hershman erroneously said that a financial incentive for installing solar PV systems would disappear unless the Senate committee voted for the bill, which includes grandfathering.

The bill would significantly reduce the incentive available to invest in solar, but at the same time would grandfather existing solar users who had installed panels up until the end of June for the next 30 years, and allow those who installed panels after June but before 2022 to be eligible for the retail rate until 2032.

On the other hand, without the bill, once a cap is met, utilities would still have to offer net metering to existing users, although new applicants could be turned away.

This was not the information Hershman conveyed when urging lawmakers to vote for the bill last week; inaccurately stating that without changes included in his measure, consumers who currently benefit from net metering would be without any incentive once a cap was met.

“Gone. No grandfathering. No guarantee. Nothing,” he said during a hearing on 16 February.  “People ask for a reason for the bill – this is part of it.”

Hershman’s wrongful portrayal of the consequences for residential solar if his bill was not passed ultimately resulted in approval by the committee of an 8-2 vote.

Opponents of the bill argue that misstatements made by Hershman were intended to garner support for the bill, which reduces the financial incentive available through net metering as many utilities state that the retail rate of compensation allows solar users to be subsidised for their use of the grid by non-solar users.

According to reports, senator Lonnie Randolph said he ended up voting for the bill after being persuaded during the hearing, despite plans to initially vote against it.

“Knowing what I know now, I would not vote for the bill,” said Randolph.

For his part, Hershman insisted that his speech during the hearing was both “accurate” and the alleged misstatements are “a non-issue”, whilst clarifying that the bill did indeed include a grandfathering provision.

The bill has since received widespread backlash from clean energy supporters – who have spoken out against the detrimental effect SB 309 would have on Indiana’s emerging solar market, as well as Hershman’s false assertions on the bill.

Before the bill is passed under law it still awaits approval from the Statehouse. 

Read Next

May 7, 2021
US solar installer SunPower expects deployment to surge in the coming quarters as tailwinds and refreshed business strategy combine, despite installs within its core residential and light commercial (RLC) segment dropping in Q1 2021.
May 5, 2021
A round-up of news from the US solar sector, including updates from the Department of Energy, private equity firm American Securities, and Indiana developer Hoosier.
PV Tech Premium
April 30, 2021
Elon Musk pitched a new vision for Tesla’s home solar-storage product this week, labelling it a “profound” alternative to the status quo. Liam Stoker analyses Tesla’s newly-described offering, the integration of Tesla’s solar and storage into a single product and explores benefits that may have been overlooked.
April 27, 2021
A round-up of the latest news from the US, including updates from Texas-based Leeward Renewable Energy, Danish utility Ørsted, and IPP Navisun.
April 15, 2021
Asset manager Capital Dynamics will develop a 200MW solar farm for US utility Northern Indiana Public Service Company (NIPSCO) as it works towards its decarbonisation targets.
April 14, 2021
Meyer Burger is on track to start shipments of its first heterojunction (HJ) solar modules made in Germany to distributors in July.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
May 26, 2021
Session 1 - 7:00 AM (BST) | Session 2 - 5:00 PM (BST)
Solar Media Events
June 15, 2021
Solar Media Events
July 6, 2021
Solar Media Events
August 24, 2021