Net energy metering battle fires up solar industry

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Previously, all we could see were the smoke signals. San Diego Gas & Electric lost its attempt to clamp down on net energy metering (NEM) and the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) then approved a new formula to calculate the state's 5% cap, raising small-scale residential and commercial solar potential to 5,000MW.

This year, the flames are already starting to spread as the utilities push against the solar advocates on NEM, the “silent subsidy”.

The CPUC will temporarily suspend NEM for new customers at the end of 2014, once it has worked out new rules based on a review of a new cost-effectiveness study of NEM to be completed this year. The CPUC's last cost-effectiveness review could have been better news for the solar industry.

Although a report by consultants E3 published in 2009 found that the impacts of NEM were small, they said that once the 2,300MW capacity of the California Solar Initiative was fully subscribed, the cost to California's three big utility companies would be $137 million. Residential NEM customers would in effect impose a net cost of $0.19 per kWh of power exported to the grid, a cost that is shifted to non-solar customers.

Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E), San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) and Southern California Edison (SCE) have told the CPUC that the current 5% NEM cap will impose billions of dollars of additional costs on ratepayers who do not participate in the NEM programme. But many in the solar industry claim that the utilities are crying foul for no good reason.

Non-profit advocacy group, Vote Solar, was quick off the mark this year by commissioning a cost-benefit analysis from Tom Beach of Crossborder Energy, formerly also of the CPUC.

Annie Lappé, solar policy director, said: “The reason why Vote Solar is adamant about doing these cost benefit studies properly, is because the stakes are so high for current and future [distributed generation] solar users.

“Utilities that are claiming that NEM is a subsidy have proposed several options to 'remedy' the situation. To varying degrees, we believe that all the proposals on the table compared to NEM as it exists today would serve to discourage the adoption of on-site solar energy.”

Lappé said that utility proposals ranged from an increase in monthly customer service charges “as much as $50 a month could be reasonable”, imposing standby service charges, limiting NEM capacity and replacing net metering with Value of Solar Tariff, as put forward by Austin Energy, a variant of a feed-in tariff that would be recalculated annually based on the value of PV generation to the utility.

“We first want to see a proper cost-benefit analysis and if it shows that NEM provides financial benefits to all ratepayers in a utility service area or a state,” she said. “At Vote Solar, we say why change a policy that is working so well to increase use of solar.”

“The question we're really trying to answer in this study is: does the retail rate credit accurately capture the value of the power that's exported to the grid,” said Beach.

“Most NEM systems only export about one third of their power. As a matter of physics, those exports usually serve the NEM customer's neighbours, it serves nearby loads. It displaces power that the utility would have delivered to those neighbours from more remote sources. The principal cost is that utilities lose revenues when the meter runs backwards and the utility may incur billing and administration costs.”

While the E3 report found there was a net cost of about $0.14 per kWh of power exported, Beach's new study found that the net cost in the residential market has dropped by a factor of 10 to $0.013 per kWh. In SCE and SDGE territories, NEM has a small net benefit for other residential customers, the report found.

In the commercial and industrial sector, which is 60% of the market in California, the benefits were much greater, said Beach.

“Commercial and industrial rates often include significant fixed charges or demand charges that are difficult for solar customers to avoid. They have much lower volumetric energy rates and as a result the costs of net metering are significantly lower than the benefits.

“Commercial and industrial customers tend to install solar systems that are smaller compared to their load than residential customers and their exports tend to happen in the middle of the afternoon when the power is more valuable. NEM is definitely more cost effective in the commercial and industrial market.”

In total, Beach found that there were $2 million annual NEM benefits in residential and $90 million a year in the commercial and industrial sector, a sum easily absorbed by the $25 billion revenue of California's big three utilities, he said.

Susannah Churchill, policy advocate at Vote Solar, said that utilities routinely overstated the average credit on consumers' bills.

“The average bill credit is more like 22.5 cents per kilowatt hour rather than 31.7c/kwh,” she said. “Utilities often account for only one of the benefits or avoided costs that NEM solar provides to the grid. They account for the avoided cost of the conventional generation that they would have had to buy but they leave out all of the cost savings associated with new generation, including transmission and distribution investments.

“Utilities also count the impacts of all NEM system output instead of only generation that gets exported to the grid. But like energy efficiency, solar power that's used on site places no burden on the utility.

“We don't see utilities claiming that customers who turn their lights off or install energy efficient appliances should have to pay a charge for the power that they didn't buy. We think it is fundamentally unfair to look at the grid impacts of solar that's used on site differently from the grid impacts of energy efficiency.

Expect more reports, and counter reports throughout the year, as the CPUC edges towards a decision.

Last week, researchers at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory published a separate report, Electricity Bill Savings from Residential Photovoltaic Systems: Sensitivities to Changes in Future Electricity Market Conditions.

Although it doesn't advocate a position, it does lay out some of the pros and cons of what the utilities might have in mind to replace NEM.

“Under all other rate options and compensation mechanisms evaluated in this report, however, the bill savings from residential PV decline with increasing solar penetration levels on the grid,” said the authors.

“Across all of the electricity market scenarios considered, the bill savings are significantly eroded if, instead of net metering, generation from behind-the-meter PV exported to the grid is compensated at hourly wholesale prices.”

But the only thing that is certain post-2014 is that the CPUC decision will not only determine the size of California's rooftop market, but also set the pace of demand and shape consumer expectations of solar for many years to come.

1 December 2021
Join this virtual conference on 1-2 December 2021 for expert presentations covering PV Module Technology, Supply & Site Optimisation for Utility-Scale. Delegates can access streamed presentations, session recordings and chat/messaging tools to connect with fellow delegates and speakers. Speakers include leading developers, manufacturers, testing and research institutes, including: NREL, Silicon Ranch, Sonnedix, Heliene, Powertis, LONGi Solar, JinkoSolar, PVEL, Risen Energy, Seraphim, STS, Trina Solar, Eternalsun Spire, QEERI, Fraunhofer, Estuary Capital Partners, VDE, First Solar, Longroad Energy, Powertis and DNV Energy Systems
2 December 2021
Intersolar is the world’s leading exhibition & conference series for the solar industry. As part of this event series, Intersolar India in Mumbai is India’s most pioneering exhibition and conference for India’s solar industry. It takes place annually and has a focus on the areas of photovoltaics, PV production and solar thermal technologies. Since 2019, Intersolar India is held under the umbrella of The smarter E India – India’s innovation hub for the new energy world.
9 December 2021
The Smart Energy Council is hosting Australia’s second Virtual Smart Energy Conference and Exhibition on Thursday, 9 December 2021. This event will show that the industry powers on despite COVID-19 and we are standing together undeterred in spirit. Bringing our global community together using the latest technology.
13 January 2022
Intersolar North America and Energy Storage North America “Come Together” for the first time in Long Beach, CA—connecting installers, developers, utilities, technology providers, policy makers, and key stakeholders from around the world to advance the clean energy future. With best-in-class conference programming, integrated exhibits and pavilions, and the live Solar Games installer competition, #isnaesna21 will showcase the industry trends, innovative solutions, and emerging talent transforming the solar, energy storage, and e-mobility markets. Register today to redeem our exclusive offer for PV Tech readers—free expo hall or 20% off full conference pass.
1 February 2022
As Solar Finance & Investment enters its ninth year, we sit on the cusp of a new power market with solar at its heart. The 2022 edition of the event will build on our years of expertise and relationships to bring investors and lenders together with top developers. Connect with leaders in the field and use exclusive insights to drive investment and development decisions for the future. Meet new and existing project partners at the largest gathering of European solar investors and lenders.
23 February 2022
Held annually since 2016, the Energy Storage Summit Europe is the place to be for senior stakeholders in the European storage industry. Designed to accelerate deployment of storage, we examine evolving chemistries, business models, project design, revenue stacks and use cases for storage. The 2022 edition will include exclusive content around longer duration solutions, energy strategies for wide-scale deployment of EVs and "EnTech", the event which sits at the intersection of digitisation, decentralisation and decarbonation of the power system. Come to meet TSOs, DSOs, Utilities, Developers, Investors and Lenders and leave with new contacts, partners and a wealth of information.

Read Next

November 30, 2021
JinkoSolar has slashed its shipments guidance for the year, reducing its top end guidance by more than 5GW as it blamed ongoing logistics issues and port blockages.
November 30, 2021
Solar EPC company iSun is investing in US commercial PV project developer Encore Renewable Energy as part of efforts to accelerate its geographic expansion.
November 30, 2021
The CEO of Hevel Group, Igor Shakhray, will leave the company to become CEO of Unigreen Energy, a silicon wafer and cell manufacturer, which is owned by Hevel majority shareholder Ream Management LLC
November 30, 2021
South Korean LG Electronics has announced a series of new appointments as it aims to target greater growth and customer satisfaction moving into 2022, while also elevating certain critical departments to division level in order to supply them with greater resources
November 30, 2021
Solar risk manager kWh Analytics has launched a new offering that it says allows PV project owners to receive upfront payments in return for maintaining asset performance.
November 30, 2021
‘Solar Module Super League’ (SMSL) member Canadian Solar has raised US$150 million through a share offering, with proceeds set to help the manufacturer expand its energy storage arm.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
December 1, 2021
Solar Media Events
February 1, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
February 23, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 23, 2022
Austin, Texas, USA
Solar Media Events
March 29, 2022
Lisbon, Portugal