PV equipment suppliers can benefit from tracking investment cycles, not market demand

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Forecasting new order intake from PV capacity expansions and technology inflection points remains a challenge for the PV equipment supply-chain. As many of the leading, public-listed, tool suppliers prepare to report results for Q3 2011, the focus will be firmly on guidance for 2012 and the revenues that may emerge for new products recently launched.

Having to fully understand PV investment and technology cycles may be of secondary importance when new order intake and tool backlogs are increasing Q/Q. However, any misalignment with industry requirements can be exposed during a spending downturn; with the next priority to accurately anticipate an upturn in spending, such an understanding becomes critical.

Recent PV equipment supplier announcements have flagged up various issues related to the challenging environment that confronts them today: cuts in end-market incentives, customer order cancellations (attempted), delivery push-outs and revisions to customer’s bullish expansion plans (announcements) from 2H’10 and 1H’11.

But, why was there such a mismatch between equipment suppliers’ expectations in 1H’11 and the order intake reality unfolding in 2H’11? Why has this come as any great surprise?

In fact, much depends on which industry metrics are being used by each equipment manufacturer to benchmark and forecast the level of new order intake from one quarter to another.

A conclusion often tabled when order intake declines rapidly is to relate changes in new equipment orders with solar incentive cutbacks in Europe. This can prove an acceptable rationale to put to investors and shareholders, but it does divert attention from the root cause of company-specific PV book-to-bill ratios.

In fact, quarterly changes in end-market demand are not the dominant factors driving near-term changes in PV equipment order intake: downstream demand has typically played a minor role in cell manufacturers’ aspirations for capacity growth or technology change.

This article explains the background to these issues and explains why PV equipment suppliers should stop monitoring short-term (often domestic) end-market volatility and pay close attention to investment (bookings) cycles specific to their product portfolios.

The revenue reset

It is well documented that companies across every segment of the PV value-chain are assessing the scale of declining revenues and margins expected in 2012. One of the largest resets is likely to occur down through the equipment supply-chain after record CAGRs between 2009 and 2011.

The scale of the Y/Y revenue declines for the equipment supply-chain is now projected to be in the range of 40 – 50%. However, this estimate could yet turn out to be conservative if the cut-backs in CapEx allocated for 2012 are larger than originally feared.

Some of the reasons for the lack of equipment order activity are clearly visible. For example, factors such as overcapacity and oversupply are not particularly conducive to short term investments into new capacity. But it is worth noting that, historically, such issues have not necessarily prevented many PV manufacturers from investing in more capacity in an attempt to either gain market-entry or market-share.

Furthermore, end-market demand of approximately 21GW for 2011 may not be at the 30 GW level many manufacturers had hoped and planned for. But again, this demand level for 2011 has been forecast consistently during the past 18 months and does not come as any great surprise either.

GW’s of PV capacity destined to stay in good-inwards loading bays

There is another element that has yet to be factored into future capacity expansion activity that could well impact further on new order intake levels during 1H’12 – the multi-GW surplus of c-Si production equipment already being shipped during Q4 2011 with no timetabled installation dates.

The origins behind this alarming proposition can be traced back to the exuberance of APAC-based tier 2 and tier 3 c-Si manufacturers during 2H’10 and 1H’11. In their haste to add capacity, many of these manufacturers pushed the equipment supply-chain into volume tool commitments for delivery throughout 2011. With minimal trading history, ordering was often done at the expense of large upfront payments or with steep cancellation charges.

Furthermore, much of the equipment was ordered from European tool suppliers operating on fiscal calendars ending December 31. As a result, Q4 2011 will represent a period during which a significant amount of PV equipment is still shipped, but will remain in “crates” – awaiting a justification to be installed.

Exactly what is done with this equipment remains an open question. Market oversupply during 2H’11 has impacted most on tier 2 and tier 3 manufacturers that lack downstream project pipelines. Aside from ASP declines, cell and module efficiency thresholds have increased to levels that potentially render a considerable portion of standard production line yields unsellable.

Some equipment ordered 12 months ago is likely to remain idle unless incremental funding is obtained to provide the potential for enhanced efficiencies – representing the rather bizarre situation of upgrading a production line prior to any equipment being installed. Either way, the prospects for any meaningful new order intake from this (not inconsiderable) group of PV manufacturers are particularly bleak.

Market-demand dynamics are not correlated with new order intake

However, it remains almost inevitable that declining new order intake and backlogs reported by PV equipment manufacturers over the next few weeks will be attributed to policy uncertainty within Europe and softness in downstream demand throughout 2011.

Therefore, it is worth examining what link there is between Q/Q changes in end-market demand and PV equipment supplier order intake and how these metrics have been correlated in the past. Figure 1 (left, upper graph) provides such a comparison.

A quick glance at the analysis here reveals that there has been minimal value in comparing short-term Q/Q changes in PV market-demand with changes in new order intake by PV equipment suppliers: at least, within a 12 – 18 month time window.

Order intake depends on the motives driving investment into PV manufacturing

Implicit to understanding PV CapEx is the realization that any cyclical trends in PV capacity expansion are different to those observed in downstream installation levels. Clearly, a different analysis is required, other than looking at demand and policy changes. In order to do this, it is important to consider the various drivers that have historically influenced investments into PV capacity.

Providing measurable inputs that can be used to forecast order intake in the future would be extremely valuable for the PV equipment supply-chain. Preliminary analysis towards this goal is shown in Figure 2 (left, lower graph).

This graph compares the Q/Q change in PV equipment order intake against two different measureable parameters. First, the Q/Q change in midstream cell/module production is shown for reference. Then a second form of analysis is undertaken to factor in Q/Q changes in upstream inventory levels, utilization of effective ramped (not year-end nameplate) capacities, tier 3 thin-film investment cycles and downstream demand. Weightings are assigned to each of these secondary influences that are considered important to decision-making when adding incremental capacity.

To date, by far the dominant factor driving capacity expansion sign-off has been the Q/Q change in fab productivity – almost regardless of market demand levels or whether shipped panels were merely swelling downstream inventory warehouses.

Typically, the enthusiasm derived from increasing fab production has been sufficient to stimulate new investments and new participants to the industry. This in turn has resulted in strong – and closely correlated – Q/Q increases in PV equipment supplier order intakes.

Therefore, while equipment suppliers may seek solace from any spike in downstream installations reported during Q4 2011, it remains unlikely that this will translate into an upturn in fab expansion commitments and new order intakes.

As 2012 unfolds, it will become increasingly important to focus on the key factors that are driving equipment spending cycles within the industry. This will include strong contributions from the push towards higher cell efficiencies (irrespective of excess capacity) and the continuing industry consolidation toward low cost manufacturing centres.

19 July 2022
Free webinar - Hear an updated and live talk that was first delivered by PV Tech's Head of Research, Dr Finlay Colville at the PV ModuleTech conference in Napa on 15 June 2022: - The PV industry has moved beyond its legacy supply/demand dynamics: why has this happened? - ASPs can’t go down globally in the near to mid-term: why is this the case? - Is there new capacity coming to the rescue? - Has China’s polysilicon industry become a new PV pricing cartel? - Making products & deploying domestically in a TW annual landscape: how can the U.S. really do this in practice? - The real PV technology roadmap: why do only 2% of producers matter today?
19 July 2022
As New South Wales is gearing up to become a renewable energy superpower, an exciting clean energy event is coming to Sydney. Energy Next is a free-to-attend industry event focusing on the latest renewable energy and energy management technologies, which will be held from 19-20 July 2022 at the ICC Sydney in Darling Harbour. Organised by the same people behind the country’s largest clean energy event, All-Energy Australia, Energy Next will bring a quality exhibition and technical session series to NSW. Energy Next will also host the Clean Energy Council’s Solar Masterclass with a program developed for solar designers and installers. Across two days, Energy Next will provide an extensive exhibition, workshops and networking opportunities for those working in the renewable energy industry to meet with leading suppliers, discover the latest technologies and gain an understanding of how to successfully launch new clean energy projects.
20 July 2022
Join us for this free webinar on 20th July as Finlay Colville, Head of Research at Solar Media, provides a detailed update on the UK's solar industry today: Where is growth coming from, how much deployment is likely over the next 12-18 months? The large-scale solar farm pipeline at 40 GW and still going up – how much is getting built today? Commercial rooftops - the big story of UK solar in 2022; but is this just the tip of the iceberg? Why are PV module prices going up? What will happen in the next couple of years? The era of PV modules at 500 Watts and above: what is driving this?
21 July 2022
The rooftop solar PV market is set for significant growth, but installers are being held back by complicated design software that is slow, cumbersome and fails to take into account rooftop shading, module compatibility and energy storage. Huawei’s SmartDesign 2.0 is a web-based PV and energy storage system tool that promises to solve all of those issues, and much more. This webinar will provide a live demonstration of the SmartDeisgn 2.0 tool, showing how installers can quickly complete Huawei PV & ESS system designs and assemble a professional report with 3D site view for potential customers, streamlining the design and sales service.
27 July 2022
The corporate renewable market is growing rapidly driven by increasing focus on decarbonisation and sustainability. There are several procurement options already popular today – open access, rooftop solar, RECs and green tariffs. Some new procurement routes as well as technologies are emerging – VPPA, storage, round-the-clock PPAs etc. Each procurement option comes with unique benefits and challenges related to policy and regulatory framework, commercial feasibility, contractual terms, execution and operational aspects. This programme is designed to empower business managers with adequate knowledge and skills to analyse different procurement options and develop an optimal roadmap based on their individual needs. The programme will be conducted by BRIDGE TO INDIA team supported by leading experts from the renewable energy industry.
27 July 2022
As solar PV projects embrace large-format and bifacial PV modules, inverters are evolving to deliver benefits across all three main LCOE variables, namely Capex, Opex and yield. However, asset operators are also demanding more oversight of the health of their projects, in turn demanding even more from modern inverter technology. This webinar will discuss how modern solar inverters have evolved to keep pace with PV module technology, providing real-life examples of how GoodWe has solved challenges for solar project developers and asset managers.

Read Next

PV Tech Premium
July 6, 2022
The company behind a renewables project that will feature 7GW of solar PV and 5GW / 20GWh of battery storage in Morocco is progressing with offshore surveying for four high-voltage direct current (HVDC) cables that will eventually connect the installation exclusively to the UK.
July 6, 2022
Energy major Shell will start constructing a renewable hydrogen plant in the Netherlands that it said will be the largest project of its kind in Europe when operational in 2025.
July 6, 2022
US power distribution company Entergy Arkansas has issued a request for proposals (RfP) for 1GW of solar and wind resources.
PV Tech Premium
July 6, 2022
Mark Osborne assesses solar research and development spends of the last decade, contextualising the industry’s current transition to TOPCon and how it has been driven.
July 6, 2022
Polish developer R.Power is seeking a primary equity capital raise to fund its future growth plans in several European countries.
July 6, 2022
US PV developer Birch Creek Development has increased its existing credit facility with debt financing provider Fundamental Renewables to US$250 million to pursue its 5GW solar pipeline in the US and support its module procurement strategy.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
July 19, 2022
Free Webinar - 10am and 6pm BST
Upcoming Webinars
July 27, 2022
9am (UTC +2) / 3pm (UTC +8)
Solar Media Events
October 4, 2022
New York, USA