PV Talk: Behind the record low bids in India’s state solar auctions

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on reddit
Reddit
Share on email
Email

This week PV Tech revealed the results of India’s latest solar auction in the state of Punjab and once again the winning bids came in very low. In a similar fashion to the summer’s two other state solar auctions in Madhya Pradesh and Telangana, the winning prices for Punjab came in at well under INR6/kWh (US$0.09). This is despite a recent analysis from Mercom Capital Group citing several bankers saying that only prices of INR6-6.5 per unit would be workable given India’s current market conditions.

PV developer SkyPower Southeast Asia Holdings' winning of a 50MW solar plant at a record low price of INR5.05/kWh in Madhya Pradesh prompted a stream of industry figures to express concern about the viability and quality of projects with such low tariffs. This was followed by news of winning projects having trouble signing power purchase agreements (PPAs) in Madhya Pradesh and peculiar project allocations in Telangana due to a substation-based bidding process. Concern was then heightened after PV developer Photon won a 50MW project in Punjab at INR5.09/kWh this week.

Tobias Engelmeier, the founder and managing director of consultancy firm Bridge to India, spoke to PV Tech about what lies behind these low bids and whether they really are as reckless as some would have us believe.

Tobias Engelmeier, founder and managing director of consultancy firm Bridge to India Image: Bridge to India
Engelmeier 'There are other players who want to be pioneers in this market and are ready to make almost any bet'. Image: MNRE

How will projects with such low prices come to fruition and who will finance them?

We predicted that developers would bid aggressively, but the lowest bids were lower than expected. There are always outliers. The projects will get built, but some owners will not get strong returns, because the margins are so low.

Low tariffs can still be bankable. There are various types of recourse finance available. Also, there are different types of contractual details in loan agreements, so just because a project is below a certain price does not mean that banks will not finance it.

What is really behind these low bids?

There are more and more players willing to come into the market at increasingly competitive tariffs. It means that they are making various aggressive assumptions about their business. 

Some players in the market are focusing on building a solar asset base, even if individual projects don’t yield returns. They then aim to give that asset base a value, which is more than the current value of returns from the individual projects within that asset base. There is scope for refinancing, of course. Yet, value expectations seem to go beyond that. It is unclear what that extra value could be.

The market is currently split into two. There are players who say there is no additional value and the returns of projects are not attractive, and therefore they don’t enter the market. They are standing on the side lines and watching in wonder at what is happening. Then there are other players who want to be pioneers in this market and are ready to make almost any bet.

Why does Madhya Pradesh appear reluctant to sign PPAs with some winning companies from its auction such as Hero Future Energies and Renew Power?

If you are a developer and take part in a tariff action, then your best result is to be at the high end of winning projects. That is the game. Now, the Madhya Pradesh government has said some players are giving power at ~INR5/kWh and therefore it should not have to pay the other winning players a rupee more. It has not yet issued Letters of Interest to Hero Future Energies and ReNew Power. This is not acceptable. Other than undermining confidence in the government’s processes, it would hold everyone in the market hostage to the lowest bidder. And the lowest bidder, as discussed before, might have other ideas than maximising project returns. I don’t think Madhya Pradesh will go down that path, I think it will sign the PPAs.

Why have some developers with less competitive bids been allocated capacity in Telangana?

The Telangana bidding is held around specific substations, which means that a developer must own land near that substation to be able to evacuate power through it. It splits the market from a state level to a substation level. While this makes sense from a point of view of maximising the use of existing infrastructure, it could create a market around certain substations that is no longer competitive. It is possible to have just two players owning suitable land near a certain substation. They then could win at tariffs that give them more profit than they would need. The state is at risk of overpaying. It just shows how difficult good market design is. By and large, however, the Telangana bid was very well handled. 

Is there concern about Punjab’s suitability for solar given the low winning bids? 

Punjab is the food basket of India. It has plenty of fertile land and agriculture. As a result, land prices are high. It is not the place to build large amounts of solar, whereas if you look at Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Gujarat, even places in Tamil Nadu, there is unused land and baking heat, which makes these states suitable for solar. Punjab having tariffs at a similar rate to Madhya Pradesh makes little sense.

More solar auctions are coming up in Maharashtra, Karnataka, Gujarat and Uttar Pradesh. Do you expect to see similarly low prices? 

I think so. Unless something dramatically changes on the cost side, which I don't foresee, then we can expect prices of between INR5-5.50/kWh. Market tariffs are “sticky” once expectations have been set. 

28 September 2021
Solar Solutions International is the largest trade show for solar energy in Northwest Europe. Now the solar market has grown up, it's time for the next step. Solar Solutions International displays more than 500 innovations and over 100 practical seminars concerning the latest in energy storage, smart products, and an ever evolving array of solar panels. As an exclusively B2B trade show, Solar Solutions International offers both exhibitors and visitors the chance to network at the highest level. Duurzaam Verwarmd, the largest trade show for sustainable HVAC technology in the Benelux, is held simultaneously. This way your one visit gets you up to date with all of the developments in both sustainable energy and heating.
6 October 2021
Intersolar Europe is the world’s leading exhibition for the solar industry. It takes place as part of The smarter E Europe – the continent’s largest platform for the energy industry. Under the motto “Connecting solar business,” manufacturers, suppliers, distributors, service providers and project planners and developers from around the world meet in Munich every year to discuss the latest developments and trends, explore innovations firsthand and meet potential new customers.
6 October 2021
The future is bright for a new era of US solar and storage, and the 8th annual Solar & Storage Finance Summit will provide opportunities to discuss solutions to the industry’s challenges and provide a networking platform designed to bring together the top minds in the industry to do business. With a mix of high-level, informative presentations and panels, a stellar cast of speakers and audience members with deal-making capacity, the 2021 edition of the event will be a sell-out success.
18 October 2021
Intersolar South America, South America’s largest exhibition and conference for the solar industry, takes place at the Expo Center Norte in São Paulo, Brazil on October 18–20, 2021, and has a focus on the areas of photovoltaics, PV production and solar thermal technologies. At the accompanying Intersolar South America Conference, renowned experts shed light on hot topics in the solar industry.
19 October 2021
This year’s EV World Congress will hold a special role, not only as the first live EverythingEV event in over a year – a chance to renew your connections and re-engage with the EV sector face to face – but also as a chance to share insight and inspiration as world starts to look towards move on post COVID towards hitting ambitious decarbonisation goals in 2030 and beyond. As ever, we will be bringing world leading organisations, cities, and technology providers to the UK to inspire EV innovators, and delve into the challenges facing the sector as the UK looks to revolutionise road transport.
20 October 2021
Utility-scale solar is evolving, shaped by higher power modules and demand for increasingly lower levelised cost of electricity (LCOE). Those trends are also changing project requirements elsewhere, with inverters capable of delivering high power density and power capacity in strong demand. In this webinar, FIMER will detail how its innovative high-power, multi-MPPT string inverter and modular conversion solution can both meet those demands and transform the utility-scale solar sector for the better.

Read Next

September 24, 2021
Independent power producer Catalyze has acquired commercial and industrial (C&I) solar developer Sol Alliance, expanding its presence in the northeast of the US and taking on an 80MW project development pipeline in the process.
September 24, 2021
California Governor Gavin Newsom has signed a US$15 billion package to fund programmes to tackle drought and climate change in the state
PV Tech Premium
September 24, 2021
Concerns have been raised that new measures introduced by Spain’s government to limit windfall profits of renewable energy plants could dent investor confidence and impact the stability of the country’s solar sector.
September 24, 2021
DNV-owned solar monitoring firm GreenPowerMonitor is to integrate Alteso’s solar analytics tech platform into its offering after striking a deal to acquire it.
September 23, 2021
A project that bids to combine up to 20GW of solar PV with the world’s largest energy storage battery and a 4,200km-long subsea power cable has moved a step forward after Indonesian authorities greenlit its proposed transmission cable route.
September 23, 2021
US national residential and C&I solar plant performance assessment company Omnidian has completed a US$33 million Series B raise.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
October 6, 2021
Solar Media Events
October 19, 2021
BRISTOL, UK
Solar Media Events
December 1, 2021