Quest for consensus as some in solar industry seek peace agreement

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Debate over net energy metering has become so divided it sometimes seem that there is no way to cross this particular chasm.

The story so far is of hugely successful companies such as SolarCity and Sunrun installing solar systems to the chagrin of utilities who see their already low margins cut further by these rooftop revolutionaries fuelled by third party ownership (TPO).

In Arizona, the debate has turned ugly with an all-out war against net energy metering, a major driver in the adoption of solar.

But somewhere amid it all there has to be some consensus. All wars between nations and rivals come to an end, eventually, leaving the spirit of competition to express itself in sporting arenas or on open markets.

Some companies have opted for outright confrontation in trying to beat the utilities at their own game, while others appear to want a more conciliatory, collegiate approach.

Kristian Hanelt, senior vice president of renewable capital markets at Clean Power Finance (CPF), said: “Third party financing and its increasing penetration poses strategic and operating challenges for regulated utilities. The more customers go solar, utilities will be required to amortise their fixed cost of maintaining the grid across a smaller base of people buying electricity from them. That causes the utilities to have to raise rates for those homeowners, which encourages them to go solar at an increasing rate.”

It's a vicious cycle or virtuous circle depending on which side of the debate you're on. But Hanelt is optimistic that utilities can profit from solar.

“Solar has great implications for utilities as we think about the short, medium and long term,” he said. “We've established that solar is popular and trending towards greater adoption and more markets. We've established that the economics are sustainable in the current net metering regime and current federal and state subsidies, even when those go away. We've established that it's a great investment [people] will continue to invest in solar even in the face of rising interest rates because of the risk return that it pays out.”

Hanelt's company is participating in an initiative led by the Rocky Mountain Institute to try to bridge that yawning chasm over the costs of solar to non-solar customers. The main objective of the Electricity Innovation Lab (eLab) is to address three key challenges: understanding the costs and benefits of distributed generation (DG); harmonisation of business models of utilities and DG developers; acceleration of the adoption of distributed resources.

James Tong, senior director of programmes at CPF, told PV Tech: “RMI saw as we did that there was a brewing fight over NEM where utilities saw it as a threat to their existence.

“RMI believes that as we do that there is a middle ground where solar can peacefully co-exist with the utilities – in fact the utilities can make money from solar; it's just a matter of reconfiguring their business and updating their business model.”

If you look at the participants in eLab, the giants of third-party ownership (TPO) are absent [see slide 1]. It's impossible to tell if this is significant, but it makes CPF's approach seem all the more emollient.

CPF analysis suggests that even if utilities lose market share, the pie is so big that no one needs to go hungry.

“We think of solar as the next wave of consumer financing… we do believe within the next year it will be a US$6 billion annual market,” said Hanelt during a Solar Electric Power Association webinar last week. “Fifty-six million homes can refinance their electricity bills with solar – but only 1% of the market has been penetrated.”

Even when the Investment Tax Credit drops from 30% to 10% from 2016, McKinsey data shows that the economics of solar remains strong assuming annual utility rate increases of a very conservative 2.5%, an 8% yield for investors and continued decline in system costs [see slide 2].

“When that tax credit goes down to 10% in 2017 and 2018 you get to a $3.20/w cost [of installation],” he said. “That is fairly common today in terms of where the best in class solar installers and originators are operating. We already see folks today at these numbers and below. That's a very good sign for the industry being sustainable without a federal tax credit of 30%.

Solar has a great risk-return profile that yields 12% for investors [see slide 3].

“We expect and plan that over the next number of years, that 12% will come down significantly commensurate with the size of the balloon increasing dramatically,” said Hanelt. “That is what gives us great confidence that there is going to continue to be lots of capital available for residential solar.”

That's good news that just gets better when you consider how much further balance-of-system costs could decline.

“California today is basically where Germany was in the first quarter of 2009 –what Germany has done that California still needs to get better at is reducing soft costs. Those have replaced modules as the most expensive part of installing a solar system today. If you think about what are the primary cost drivers of profitably selling and installing a solar system today it used to be modules now it's the cost of customer acquisition, costs of permitting and being efficient with labour costs.

“Germany can serve as a very good blueprint and guidepost for what kinds of cost decline are possible over the next few years while we still have that 30% tax credit. You can see Germany is now installing for approximately $2.20/W.”

Received wisdom assumes that TPO either through a lease or power purchase agreement (PPA) is going to be the dominant model for some time to come. But others in the industry, such as Admirals Bank, have tried to argue that loan products such as theirs will become increasingly attractive as costs decline. So confident is it that it can compete in California, Admirals Alternatives established a San Francisco office in recent weeks.

Hanelt agrees, but only to a very limited extent – hardly surprising given that the CDF model is based on TPO.

“Everybody's saying that people are going to finance using loans because these systems are going to get so cheap,” he said. “That's right on one level, but I do not believe that loans will replace PPAs and leases as the dominant financing product. If you look at what loans do.”

PPAs and leases offer the lowest monthly payments and monetise the ITC efficiently and TPO companies offer a full service throughout the lifetime of the contract.

“A big driver of why people like to finance solar is operations and maintenance,” he said. “If I'm going to finance a solar system for 20 years I want to make sure it's taken care of and it's producing so that the benefit of avoiding utility electricity purchases is as I expected it would be. Most loan products today do not include any kind of maintenance monitoring or performance guarantees, mechanisms that are all very common in loans and PPAs and leases.”

But loans have their place in states where there are generous state-based taxes, he said. North Carolina, for example, offers a 35% personal tax credit for renewable projects.

If there is a bright spot for utilities, it could be in servicing, he said: “If you look at 2013, we expect about 100,000 homes will go solar this year, the majority of those through financing, and we expect that number to double by 2016 to 200,000 homes. Even at those numbers we're still just a fraction of penetration of the US housing market and this is going to be an industry that continues to grow and scale as time goes on.”

26 January 2022
Join this free webinar for our analysis of the growth of N-Type technology including; new capacity expansions and production output. We'll also be looking at the global manufacturing footprint with forecasts on how much product will be made outside of China this year and which companies are driving technology change across the crystalline silicon value chain.
23 February 2022
Held annually since 2016, the Energy Storage Summit Europe is the place to be for senior stakeholders in the European storage industry. Designed to accelerate deployment of storage, we examine evolving chemistries, business models, project design, revenue stacks and use cases for storage. The 2022 edition will include exclusive content around longer duration solutions, energy strategies for wide-scale deployment of EVs and "EnTech", the event which sits at the intersection of digitisation, decentralisation and decarbonation of the power system. Come to meet TSOs, DSOs, Utilities, Developers, Investors and Lenders and leave with new contacts, partners and a wealth of information.
7 March 2022
Take your chance to join the most powerful platform in the MENA region. Middle East Energy (MEE), Intersolar, and ees, the leading energy exhibitions are joining hands to co-deliver an outstanding renewables and energy storage event at Middle East Energy 2021. Renewables and energy storage at MEE is the largest gathering of solar and renewable energy industry professionals in the Middle East & Africa, offering the most effective trade focused platform to international manufacturers and distributors looking to meet regional buyers.
8 March 2022
As Solar Finance & Investment enters its ninth year, we sit on the cusp of a new power market with solar at its heart. The 2022 edition of the event will build on our years of expertise and relationships to bring investors and lenders together with top developers. Connect with leaders in the field and use exclusive insights to drive investment and development decisions for the future. Meet new and existing project partners at the largest gathering of European solar investors and lenders.
23 March 2022
When it comes to storage, the US market exceeded a gigawatt of advanced energy storage installations (weighted towards lithium ion) at 1.46 GW, more than the previous six years in total! An exponential growth rate could see the market hit 7.5 GW p.a. by 2025. The summit will provide a wealth of content around this vital piece in the US power puzzle, with sessions dedicated to explore how companies are making money from batteries, the latest chemistries and their applications as they apply to different use-cases. We ask how investors can match ESG criteria to batteries and we will bring case studies of successful deployment and project execution onto the stage to examine how you can ensure your own projects are successful.
29 March 2022
Now in its 10th sell-out year, Large Scale Solar returns to Lisbon in 2022. We are excited to gather together face-to-face with the European solar industry as we provide unique and exclusive access to a powerful selection of the market's key stakeholders. Join this elite summit to find out how the market is maturing, which new markets are becoming more exciting, how technology is evolving and who's driving the market forward into the 2020s. Always senior, packed with developers, EPCs, utilities and investors this is the event for companies serious about European solar PV.

Read Next

PV Tech Premium
January 18, 2022
olar project developer Eco Energy World is aiming to “aggressively” grow its US PV pipeline after formally entering the market last week and intends to replicate the cheaper engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) costs it sees in Europe in the country. PV Tech Premium speaks to CEO Svante Kumlin to find out more.
January 18, 2022
PV inverter specialist Huayu New Energy has upgraded its portfolio of single-module microinverters, launching them in the Brazilian market this month.
January 18, 2022
Trina Solar’s tracker manufacturing unit TrinaTracker has launched a 1P single-row tracker, dubbed Vanguard.
January 18, 2022
Spanish solar company Soltec Power Holdings, through its subsidiary Powertis, has sold a controlling stake in 421MW of its solar PV projects and 90MW of energy storage in Italy to German investment firm Aquila Capital under a co-development agreement.
January 18, 2022
Solar tracker manufacturer Soltec has signed contracts to supply 610MW of its SF7 bifacial trackers to Enel Green Power for use in two PV plants in Peru and Colombia.
January 18, 2022
Prefabricated solar solutions manufacturer 5B is looking to improve the scalability and cost of its technology through an AU$33.4 million (US$24 million) innovation programme and support from the Australian Renewable Energy Agency (ARENA).

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
January 26, 2022
Free Webinar
Solar Media Events
February 23, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 8, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 23, 2022
Austin, Texas, USA
Solar Media Events
March 29, 2022
Lisbon, Portugal