Solar player emerges as natural gas export’s unlikely champion

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Solar industry leaders and natural gas companies might not be a match made in heaven under ordinary circumstances. But as the US shale gale has demonstrated, we live in extraordinary times, particularly in the energy industry.

Despite the shale gas boom in America, which could quite possibly be the only thing that has spared the economy the deeper recession experienced by Europe, producers are struggling with record low prices.

In 2008, natural gas fetched US$8 per MMBtu in the domestic market. Prices reached a record low of $2 in 2012 and have this year stabilised at around $3.40 per MMBtu. But that's still short of covering costs by $0.60 per MMBtu for many producers.

Stocks for leading producers such as Chesapeake Energy, Devon Energy and Southwestern Energy have taken a battering. Chesapeake has resorted to selling assets to raise $ 7 billion, The Economist reported earlier this month.

Pressure is mounting now to convert the Gulf coast LNG import hubs into export hubs. These hubs were built only a few years ago when projections predicted a shortfall of natural gas but producers want to sell into different markets. You can see why with prices in Asia at $16 per MMBtu and Europe at $15 per MMBtu. Sabine Pass in Louisiana could be one of the first to start sending gas overseas from 2015.

Debate rages in Washington over this American resource. The Department of Energy commissioned a report from NERA Economic Consulting, which concluded that LNG export has net benefits to the US economy.

Oil and gas companies appear to be lobbying for it. Even companies in associated industries are pressuring the administration to switch the terminals. General Electric has invested hundreds of millions in the development of a new generation of gas-fired power plants and would love the American fuel supply to follow its engineering to countries such as Japan.

But now an unlikely champion has entered the natural gas export debate: Arno Harris, chief executive of Recurrent Energy, a utility-scale solar developer.

Harris argued in recent piece on CNN that: “If gas prices were still at the levels they were three years ago, wind and solar would be solidly competitive with fossil-fired power, and the utility-scale renewable industry wouldn't be fighting the headwinds it is today.”

Separately he told PV-Tech: “I wanted to shed some light on the fact that there are a lot of interests especially within the electricity sector and within the renewable industry.

“There is a strong degree of support for gas export both within the administration and within the oil and gas industry. We don't always find ourselves on the same side of an issue as the oil and gas industry but producers are really in a challenging position. They've had this tremendous success in unlocking this gas, prices have collapsed and they're unable to capture that gas at a profit. There's clearly a huge economic imperative on the part of producers to be able to connect to that global market to be able to deliver that gas and be able to realise a better price.”

Naturally, Harris isn't in this for the natural gas producers. In Recurrent Energy's market segment, solar power contracts out at utility scale at 6c or 7c per kilowatt hour wholesale. That would be competitive with natural gas prices at $6-$7 per MMBtu, still well below the price in Asia or Europe.

“But at the suppressed price as a result of the glut, it's widened the apparent difference between fossils and renewables and that creates challenges,” he said.

“It's going to be very difficult to prevent the gas coming out of the ground. We need to enable that gas to reach export markets so we're not stuck with an artificially low price in the US and we can restore some balance to the power markets. That gas is a tremendous boon and bounty to the world in terms of our energy needs.”

So far, Harris is a lone voice in the industry – but perhaps the first or just the boldest to stick his head above the parapet.

However, he does sit on the board of the Solar Energy Industries Association, but insists that the association has not taken a position on natural gas exports regardless of the benefit to solar.

Rhone Resch, chief executive and president of SEIA, said: “We don't have a position on natural gas exports. Arno was speaking on behalf of himself, certainly not for SEIA, we're focused purely on policy that affects the solar industry.

“One would think this is going to be an interesting political and economic discussion and if we get invited into those debates, we'll develop a position at that time but certainly it behooves us to focus more on solar.”

Resch might be well positioned to participate in the debate. Before joining SEIA he was senior vice president at the Natural Gas Supply Association, which represents major and independent producers of domestic natural gas.

Other studies also suggest Harris might well get his way on exports. Last year, Michael Levi proposed a framework for exports in a Hamilton Project paper that found the benefits of allowing exports outweighs the cost of constraint.

But for some, it might just be a waiting game as price balance is restored to natural gas over time.

Danny Kennedy, founder and chief executive of Sungevity, focused on the residential market, said:

“His view is from someone serving the wholesale market – solar's advantage is in the retail rates. But I don't buy the premise that natural gas is cheap for an extended period of time. 

“Gas prices are going up and evidence points to it going in that direction. Just wait till Chesapeake or someone else in the industry implodes on the back of the fact that fracking is not the panacea that has been promised.”

Kennedy warned there may be worse to come if the US locks in its dependence on natural gas only to find that dependence is based on an unsustainable shale bubble.

“We've been here before with gas companies – Enron just gouging the system and manipulating our energy policy and planning with the promise of short-term crackerjack staff and not really delivering.”

Price shock from shipping out domestic supplies to bulk up domestic prices isn't too far fetched.

Kennedy pointed to the work of Deborah Rogers who has said that the shale bonanza may come to an abrupt halt.

In a report Shale and Wall Street, Rogers suggests that the natural gas price decline might have been orchestrated by financial institutions looking for the next fast buck.

In 2011, shale mergers and acquisitions accounted for $46.5 billion in deals and became one of the largest profit centres for some Wall Street investment banks, she said.

“Wall Street promoted the shale gas drilling frenzy, which resulted in prices lower than the cost of production and thereby profited [enormously] from mergers & acquisitions and other transactional fees,” she wrote.

“Exportation is now being pursued for the arbitrage between the domestic and international prices in an effort to shore up ailing balance sheets invested in shale assets.”

If she's right, the future could look brighter yet for solar with or without large-scale shale gas exports. But in the meantime, solar and natural gas could be a marriage of convenience, even if they never learn to love each other.

19 August 2021
The utility-scale PV market is poised for exponential growth and yet the industry still has many fundamental opportunities to improve on standards and best practice. Tracker shade loss has been one of those topics that deserve more attention, but has been typically handled by derate factors rather than trying to accurately forecast the loss over the life of the system. Join Nextracker’s subject matter experts, Aron Dobos and Neelesh Umachandran, and Rounak Kharait, director of solar energy assessments at DNV, for a webinar about why shade modeling matters and recommendations on what the solar industry should do about it.
25 August 2021
Energy Next is a new industry exhibition focusing on the latest renewable energy and energy efficiency technology, which will be held for the first time in 2021 in Sydney, Australia alongside the Clean Energy Council’s Australian Clean Energy Summit, the peak gathering of leaders driving Australia's energy transformation. Organised by the same people behind Australia’s largest clean energy event, All-Energy Australia, Energy Next will give visitors two days of access to key suppliers in the industry, free-to-attend professional development and industry workshops, and networking opportunities to better understand clean energy issues and solutions and learn about the latest developments in this transformational, dynamic sector.
25 August 2021
The Intersolar Summit Brasil Nordeste takes place in Fortaleza, Brazil. It addresses leading local and international experts on solar power and renewable energy in the region. The Summit’s mission is to provide in-depth education, enable high-quality networking opportunities, expand the use of PV technologies at regional and national level and strengthen the local PV industry. The Intersolar Summit Brasil Nordeste is organized by Intersolar South America - Latin America’s largest exhibition and conference for the solar industry: Solar Promotion International GmbH, Pforzheim, Freiburg Management and Marketing International GmbH (FMMI) and Aranda Eventos & Congressos Ltda, São Paulo as co-organizer.
25 August 2021
Join us to hear directly from the CTOs and heads-of-research from the top-20 cell/wafer producers to the PV industry today. The event will focus on predicting the key metrics underpinning the next big shift to n-type with answers to the key questions: When will the transition to n-type happen? Which companies will be first to 10 GW capacity and production? Who will be the key equipment suppliers for the new production lines? Which n-type process flow/architecture will emerge as the front-runner? What will polysilicon purity and wafer thickness levels look like for optimized n-type manufacturing? What will the upstream poly/wafer supply-chain look like in 5 years from now?
26 August 2021
In this webinar, JA Solar will present its product portfolio based on the latest technologies to improve your PV projects, ensuring maximum reliability and performance. During the webinar we will receive insight from JA Solar about its solar technology roadmap and how the manufacturer is providing customers with innovative solutions to suit their needs, while we will also analyse how to determine the best product solution for each solar project.
6 September 2021
The 38th European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference and Exhibition will be held online from 6 - 10 September 2021, allowing PV experts from all around the globe to participate with just one click! The EU PVSEC is the world's leading forum for PV Research and Development and the biggest Conference on PV Solar Energy worldwide. That is why PV experts from all around the globe are keen on gathering together each year to be part of this specialist’s event, to present and discuss the latest developments in Photovoltaics, to network and to conduct business.

Read Next

PV Tech Premium
July 30, 2021
Not only will solar be the dominant source of new power generation in Europe by 2025, cementing its position as the third largest market for solar globally, but the continent has placed the asset class at the very heart of its COVID-19 recovery strategy. As part of a week-long special report on PV Tech Premium, Liam Stoker, Edith Hancock and Jules Scully explore the drivers for solar in Europe, the key markets and the challenges that remain.
July 30, 2021
First Solar has unveiled plans to construct a 3.3GWdc module assembly facility in India, bolstering its manufacturing footprint outside of the US.
July 30, 2021
Anglo-Australian mining company BHP, in partnership with Canada’s TransAlta Renewables, is to build two solar farms and a battery storage system to help power its Mt Keith and Leinster nickel mines in Western Australia
July 30, 2021
German energy giant RWE has upgraded its earnings forecast for 2021 after “exceptionally positive” earnings trend
July 29, 2021
Tracker and racking provider Arctech has delivered SkySmart II tracking system to a 575MW agriculture-sharing solar project located in Nangong City, Hebei Province, China.
July 29, 2021
Unigreen Energy, owned by Hevel majority shareholder Ream Management LLC, has broken ground on a wafer and cell manufacturing plant that will produce 1.3GW of silicon n-type monocrystalline ingots and wafers as well as 1GW of heterojunction technology (HJT) solar cells.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
August 19, 2021
At 9am (PT) | 6pm (CEST)
Solar Media Events
August 25, 2021
Solar Media Events
October 6, 2021
Solar Media Events
October 19, 2021