Top executives from 14 leading Chinese PV manufacturers gather to fight SolarWorld

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Growing indignation on the part of leading Chinese PV manufacturers in relation to the ongoing trade dispute has spurred senior executives of 14 leading producers to gather and set out a coordinated plan of defence. The plan is in response to the prospect of duties being imposed on solar PV products entering the US, due to claims of price dumping that are currently under investigation by the ITC.

Organised by the China Chamber of Commerce for Import and Export of Machinery and Electronic Products (CCCME), but believed to have been led by Yingli Green’s sending of press invitations on behalf of the group, companies vowed to fight the allegations, targeting the original petitioner, SolarWorld, to withdraw the claims.

The unprecedented move saw a group of 14 – normally fiercely competitive – leading producers demonstrate a unified front, a scenario that has never been seen before, under the banner of ‘China-based Solar Industries in Response to Anti-dumping and Countervailing Investigations in the US.’

The seriousness placed on the potential duties was not lost on the Chinese producers as key industry executives were speakers at the event. These included: Guiqing Wang, vice president of the CCCME; Liansheng Miao, chairman of the board and CEO of Yingli Green Energy; Dr. Zhengrong Shi, chairman and CEO of Suntech; Jifan Gao, chairman and CEO of Trina Solar and Shawn Qu, chairman, president & CEO of Canadian Solar.

However, the meeting, which included a press conference and a detailed and lengthy statement, made clear the group’s desire not to be positioned as a catalyst for a China versus US trade war. It appeared the meeting’s aim was to separate the group from a Chinese PV industry trade group that has been pushing for counter-investigations in relation to subsidies paid by the US government and individual States themselves to US-based companies, notably polysilicon producers, which include Hemlock Semiconductor and MEMC.

The group of Chinese PV manufacturers preferred to target SolarWorld and the yet-to-be-identified other six petitioners. Emphasis was placed on SolarWorld and others having made strategic mistakes, highlighting that they do not appear to have kept up with competition.

A press statement from the group noted that, “Even if some European and US PV companies, such as SolarWorld, are underperforming in some respects, such underperformance has nothing to do with the exports of Chinese PV companies, but instead is because of their misjudgement of the growth opportunities in the market. From 2009 to 2011, the global PV production capacity grew significantly and beyond the demand of the global market.

“Due to reduced incentives, improper investment decisions and lack of scale, certain PV companies have found themselves in a disadvantageous position in the market competition. It is a normal phenomenon in market competitions. These frustrated companies should revisit and adjust their own business strategies, elevate their production and management levels, and meet consumer’s demand in a better way. They should not raise ill-founded AD/CVD investigations in the hope of creating obstacles to the normal operation of Chinese PV companies.”

Speculation and frustration has continued over the identity of the unidentified petitioners. The Chinese companies have, in their retort, also placed emphasis on the fact that the petitioners represented only a fraction of the US PV industry, suggesting that their claim in relation to jobs was an attempt to undermine the perceived legitimacy of the claims.

Soon after the SolarWorld complaint was made public, PV-Tech was told that First Solar was one of the six unidentified petitioners – a claim that has since been publicly denied by First Solar.

As it turns out, this comes as no surprise. As the lowest-cost producer of PV modules with manufacturing operations in the US, Europe and Asia, the thin-film leader has successfully continued to compete against Chinese producers. First Solar has also been in long-standing negotiations to build massive PV power plants in Mongolia, China that could be hindered – or worse – were the company to join such a petition.

However, speculation continues to surround several other US companies, with Solyndra and Evergreen Solar being classed as possible petitioners. Both companies have been involved in high-profile bankruptcies, and both had claimed that their bankruptcies were a result of competition with Chinese PV suppliers.

As both Solyndra and Evergreen Solar have entered Chapter 11 bankruptcy, they continue to operate as businesses and therefore eligible petitioners. Speculation has also centred on struggling thin-film manufacturers such as ECD as potentially being among the unidentified petitioners. The company has recently stopped production completely to combat high inventories and weak demand as conventional crystalline module prices dropped to three times lower (on a cost-per-watt basis) than ECD’s flexible thin-film products.

The Chinese PV group noted that, “The solar industry in the US generates approximately 100,000 jobs, while in comparison SolarWorld provides only 1,000 jobs. If the US market were denied access to the PV cell products of competitive prices, other 99,000 jobs would be put into a dangerous situation. That is exactly why SolarWorld’s petition is opposed by US companies from upstream raw material and equipment suppliers to downstream distributors and users, environmental protection organizations and climate experts.”

“SolarWorld, the lead petitioner of the ongoing AD/CVD investigations, is a US subsidiary of a German company, not an indigenous US company, and the other six petitioners even have never identified themselves publically. Therefore, these petitioners only account for a very small fraction of the US PV companies, and cannot represent the position of the mainstream US PV companies.”

Nevertheless, the Coalition for American Solar Manufacturing (CASM), which was set up to support the US government's investigation, said on November 28, 2011 that it claimed a total of seven US solar (cell and module) manufacturers had joined its support campaign. This is now said to have grown to include a total of 150 solar businesses, employing more that 11,000 employees.

With battle plans being made at a rapid pace, support for opposing the investigation and calls for the complaint by SolarWorld to be withdrawn are now being voiced by the Coalition for Affordable Solar Energy (CASE).

The Chinese group’s initial statement put company membership at 101 US companies covering every segment of the US solar industry chain. However, the last press release issued by CASE on November 17, 2011 claimed a membership of 52 companies that represented more than 9,600 jobs, or nearly 10% of the US solar industry workforce. With support momentum building on both sides, it is not inconceivable that CASE membership has doubled in such a short time.

On December 1, 2011 CASE announced that its membership doubled in its second week and that after three weeks membership stood at 132 companies and represented 13,134 direct solar employees at those solar firms, or 13% of the U.S. solar industry workforce. (Update end)
On more contentious grounds, the statement from leading Chinese producers raised counter claims over SolarWorld’s having been a recipient of many government support programs in the US and Germany.

“Incomplete statistics show that SolarWorld received tax breaks and public subsidies worth of US$43 million in the US in one single new facility project in Oregon in 2007, and received governmental aids in the amount of €73.15 million, €18.75 million and €45 million in the EU in 2003, 2010 and 2011 respectively.”

The statement goes on to further target SolarWorld, highlighting claims that the company had been profitable in 2010, and that its lay-off of employees in its California facilities was due to its relocation of facilities to Hillsboro, Oregon, inferring these had nothing to do with unfair practices by Chinese suppliers.

However, the statement failed to note that SolarWorld plans to idle its facility in Hillsboro for three weeks at the end of the year.

The statement also claims that SolarWorld’s third-quarter 2011 financial statements highlight that the company increased its workforce by 11% in 2011, in an attempt to dispute claims that SolarWorld had any cause to make a petition against Chinese PV producers. 

Various references in the statement were made to previous issues raised about the whole industry’s being impacted by potential duties, not least US firms as outlined by CASE previously.

“Therefore, if the US Government imposed any definitive trade restrictive measures it would cause significant losses to the upstream and downstream industries and consumers in the US, only to the benefit of a small fraction of US PV cell companies such as SolarWorld.”

Emphasis was also placed on claims that Chinese PV manufacturers had played an important role overall in the development of the PV industry in the US.

Therefore, the group was positioning itself as supporters of the US PV industry, against a trade war with China and that, “their fight in the investigations is directed against the few petitioners led by SolarWorld only.”

Time is pressing for both sides of this bitter battle as the ITC may provide notification of a preliminary determination on December 5, 2011, though full-findings could be several months away.

Ironically, another pressing issue that also affects the entire industry involved in the PV industry in the US is the need for a one-year extension to the Department of Treasury’s Section 1603 Program, which has provided tax compensation on renewable energy installations.

The program is due to expire and supporters numbering over a claimed 750 companies are pushing the US Congress to continue support as it is claimed has leveraged US$23 billion in private sector investment to support over 22,000 projects in all 50 US States and generated many thousands of new industry jobs. 

19 July 2022
As New South Wales is gearing up to become a renewable energy superpower, an exciting clean energy event is coming to Sydney. Energy Next is a free-to-attend industry event focusing on the latest renewable energy and energy management technologies, which will be held from 19-20 July 2022 at the ICC Sydney in Darling Harbour. Organised by the same people behind the country’s largest clean energy event, All-Energy Australia, Energy Next will bring a quality exhibition and technical session series to NSW. Energy Next will also host the Clean Energy Council’s Solar Masterclass with a program developed for solar designers and installers. Across two days, Energy Next will provide an extensive exhibition, workshops and networking opportunities for those working in the renewable energy industry to meet with leading suppliers, discover the latest technologies and gain an understanding of how to successfully launch new clean energy projects.
21 July 2022
The rooftop solar PV market is set for significant growth, but installers are being held back by complicated design software that is slow, cumbersome and fails to take into account rooftop shading, module compatibility and energy storage. Huawei’s SmartDesign 2.0 is a web-based PV and energy storage system tool that promises to solve all of those issues, and much more. This webinar will provide a live demonstration of the SmartDeisgn 2.0 tool, showing how installers can quickly complete Huawei PV & ESS system designs and assemble a professional report with 3D site view for potential customers, streamlining the design and sales service.
23 August 2022
Intersolar South America, South America’s largest exhibition and conference for the solar industry, takes place at the Expo Center Norte in São Paulo, Brazil, on August 23–25, 2022, and has a focus on the areas of photovoltaics, PV production and solar thermal technologies. At the accompanying Intersolar South America Conference, renowned experts shed light on hot topics in the solar industry. In 2021 – despite the Covid-19 pandemic – Intersolar South America welcomed more than 28,000 visitors and over 1,000 conference attendees over 3 days. 200+ providers showcased their products. Combining local and international expertise, Intersolar South America brings together the PV and solar thermal sector to discuss the current status and strategic trends for Latin American PV markets, as well as technology innovations and new business opportunities. Overall, distributed generation is still driving momentum in the Brazilian market.
6 September 2022
Intersolar Mexico sits at the cross-section of photovoltaics, solar heating & cooling technologies, and energy storage. The event serves as the industry’s go-to source for invaluable technology trends and premier B2B contacts in the promising Mexican solar market. From September 6–8, 2022 Intersolar Mexico together with the co-located The GREEN Expo® and Aquatech Mexico will take place in Centro Citibanamex, Mexico City.
19 September 2022
RE+ 2022 is the umbrella event that includes SPI, ESI, RE+ Power, and RE+ Infrastructure. As North America's largest renewable energy event, it's a catalyst for industry innovation that's supercharging business growth in the clean energy economy.
20 September 2022
From source to generation, from grid to consumer, the boundaries of the sector are blurring and this evolution is being shaped by established players, external disruptors, innovative start-ups and the increasingly engaged end-user. Enlit Asia is the unifying brand for POWERGEN Asia and Asian Utility Week, showcases expert knowledge, innovative solutions and foresight from industry leaders, coherent with Asian strategy to achieve a smooth transition towards a low carbon energy supply. This year, Enlit Asia will be co-located with Sustainable Energy Technology Asia (SETA) & Solar & Storage Asia (SSA).

Read Next

July 1, 2022
Hanwha Qcells’ power plant division Q ENERGY Europe has teamed up with newly rebranded Q ENERGY France to establish umbrella company Q ENERGY Solutions SE as it seeks to deepen its ties to the European market where it has a 12GW development portfolio.
July 1, 2022
The US Supreme Court has restricted the federal government’s authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from power plants in a ruling that critics have warned will hit renewables deployment and hobble the Biden administration’s climate agenda.
July 1, 2022
Off-grid pay-as-you-go solar provider Bboxx has partnered with telecommunications company Orange to launch a new solar mini-grid project to help accelerate clean energy access for households across the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).
PV Tech Premium
July 1, 2022
PV Tech Premium spoke with Cypress Creek Renewable Energy and AES Clean Energy to discuss the newly formed US Solar Buyer Consortium, its objectives, market challenges and the potential advantages it holds for US manufacturing and project development.
July 1, 2022
Energy management software company Cleartrace has secured US$20 million in a financing round to accelerate the growth of its platform.
June 30, 2022
Investor CleanCapital has acquired renewable energy developer BQ Energy, adding 300MW of late-stage solar development to its pipeline.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
October 4, 2022
New York, USA
Solar Media Events
October 11, 2022
Virtual event