US Clean Power Plan opponents say it will make building fossil fuel plants ‘virtually impossible’


Barack Obama’s Clean Power Plan is under fire from more than 20 US states, from pro-coal industry groups and from electric utilities, with the government facing legal action for the proposed action on carbon emissions and other pollution.

The final version of the administration’s plan to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in the US by 32% from 2005 levels by 2030 was put forward by the Environment Protection Agency (EPA) on Friday and was immediately met with opposition. The plan also calls for 28% of electricity nationally to come from renewable sources, with states expected to comply with the plans by 2022.

Regional politicians including North Dakota senator John Hoeven and Patrick Morrisey, West Virginia’s attorney general, made statements against the measures, with Morrisey leading the filing of a petition in the US Court of Appeals in the District of Columbia circuit. Morrisey’s petition was signed by 23 other states, while Hoeven claimed to have united a “bipartisan group of senators” against them. Both men are Republicans however, and news sources including NBC News reported that “all but two of the states in the filing are led by Republicans”.

Utility Georgia Power complained that it would have to close 4,800MW of fossil fuel generation by 2030, saying the company was “firmly committed to protecting the investments made in its operations”. John Hoeven’s office made a statement which said North Dakota’s coal plants were being treated “unfairly” and said the plan “virtually ensures no new [coal] plants can be built”.

Coal industry groups have reacted negatively, with the US National Mining Association (NMA) claiming there was “growing concern with the immediate economic consequences” of the carbon reduction plan, which is to be implemented as part of EPA’s Clean Air Act. NMA claimed its own legal challenge could prevent the closure of 200 coal mines before the plan’s implementation even begins.

Government cites health and economic benefits

The government and EPA argue the benefits of the plan would include the prevention of 3,600 premature deaths a year and save the average consumer US$85 on their electricity bills in 2030, estimating net economic benefits of the plan to be as much as US$45 billion.

The plan is not without major backers either, including voices in the incumbent energy industry. The chairman of major utility E.On North America recently called on energy firms in the US to back the plan, stating that “there needs to be clear direction and clear policies in order to make a cleaner energy future possible”. Lynn Good, president and CEO of another big utility, Duke Energy, was among other backers of the plan when it was proposed in August.

Consequences for solar

In a blog for PV Tech in September, Laura E. Stern of Nautilus Solar said there was “no doubt” the plan would lead to increased solar capacity. Discussing varies aspects of what the measures might mean for solar, Stern argued that removal of the 30% investment tax credit (ITC) incentive for solar, planned at the end of 2016, could be a barrier to achieving the plan’s target. President Obama had also announced a number of new support mechanisms for solar to go along with the Clean Power Plan however, including making another US$1 billion available for loan guarantees.

27 September 2022
The demand for rooftop solar PV is soaring, driven by falling costs of the technology against energy crises that are gripping countries globally. But while an increasing number of households turn to solar to generate their own electricity, there is now a need for more specialist equipment, technologies and services to ensure the solar transition can reach as many customers as possible. Delivering these is now a major challenge for rooftop solar installers. This webinar will analyse the characteristics of the rooftop solar market, discussing how the products, logistics, installation and servicing of solar systems has evolved in line with consumer demands.
4 October 2022
Solar & Storage Finance USA, the only event that connects developers to capital and capital to solar and storage projects, will be back in November 2022.
11 October 2022
RE+ Florida returns in 2022. Solar & Energy Storage Florida is now RE+ Florida! This premier event for the Sunshine State will return October 11-12, 2022 in Miami.
11 October 2022
PV CellTech Extra will be held as a series of live webinars and on-demand sessions on 11-13 October 2022. We'll be taking a slightly further forward-looking view at the technologies and roadmaps for new cell architectures set to dominate mass production during 2023-2025 with special emphasis on the potential timelines for technologies beyond the single-junction cell design, including perovskite and hybrid concepts.
13 October 2022
The 2022 ACORE Grid Forum is a one-day event that convenes regulators, renewable, storage and transmission companies, and other leading grid experts in Washington, D.C. Speakers will examine the roles of administrative orders and actions, infrastructure policy, regional and state developments, and private sector strategies on the path to a carbon-free grid.
18 October 2022
The solar, storage and EV industries in the UK are going from strength to strength. There is no better place for the community to meet, share ideas and do business than Solar & Storage Live from 18-20 October at the NEC. There’s something for everyone; more than 150 exhibitors, a high-level conference, a start up and innovation zone, a poster zone, strategic partners to network with and much more. 

Read Next

September 27, 2022
Nearly a third of all renewable technologies employment came from the solar PV industry in 2021, according to a new report from the IRENA.
September 27, 2022
Greek developer Mytilineos has completed third-party engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contracts on a backlog of solar PV projects in Chile, Uzbekistan and Spain.
PV Tech Premium
September 27, 2022
Europe must build out its own large-scale, vertically integrated solar PV manufacturing base as a means to ensure its clean energy transition.
September 27, 2022
Module manufacturer Boviet Solar has secured an 861MW supply agreement with US renewables developer Vesper Energy.
September 27, 2022
The European Technology and Innovation Platform for Photovoltaics (ETIP PV) has been relaunched to advise policymakers and promote the uptake of solar across Europe.
September 27, 2022
Tongwei has announced plans to sign an investment agreement to develop a 25GW high-efficiency PV module manufacturing base in China

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
September 27, 2022
15:30 AEST (UTC +10)
Solar Media Events
October 4, 2022
New York, USA
On-Demand Webinars, Solar Media Events
October 11, 2022
Virtual event
Upcoming Webinars
October 18, 2022
10am (EDT) / 4pm (CEST)