Utilities fear what they cannot control with community solar

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Utilities love solar. Or at least they love utility-scale solar, i.e. installations they can own or control through power purchase agreements. But as the battle with net energy metering has shown, utilities fear what they cannot control.

Some states and some utilities have embraced community solar, particularly in the western United States. No surprises there. Colorado, thanks in part to its Solar Gardens Act, has seen community solar flourish.

And towards the end of last month, California's two community solar bills currently before the legislature made it through critical votes. AB 1014 passed with a resoundingly positive 49 to 15 votes before heading to the Senate, while the Assembly will consider SB43 this month.

The Solar Electric Power Association and the Interstate Renewable Energy Council (IREC) are keeping track of community solar, state by state.

The major trend from its “matrix” is easy to spot: the push for community solar has largely been driven by cooperative and municipal utilities.

Besides Colorado, where Xcel Energy indeed excels at bringing community solar to its customers, many investor-owned utilities seem to be struggling with the concept of sharing, even in California.

San Diego Gas & Electric probably has the most to fear in terms of residential solar growth in its territory. Earlier this year, Lee Krevat, director of SDG&E's smart grid division, said the utility had seen an explosive rise in rooftop solar with growth rates at around 40% a year. Last July, SDG&E recorded 400 new installations – in March there were 700 installations, he said. Goodness knows what this July's installation rate will be.

SDG&E has been an early mover with its ‘Connected to the Sun’ proposal for two pilot programmes before the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC).

“SDG&E supports solar energy and believes solar power should be affordable and easily available to any customer who wants it,” an SDG&E spokeswoman said. “SDG&E supports the concept of a shared renewable programme that is carefully crafted, and is endeavouring to implement such an option for our customers through our pending application at the CPUC.

“We believe this is the best approach for these kinds of programmes because it does not require cost shift or place a financial burden on non-participating customers.”

Cost shifts are a dubious point of contention. Utilities argue that community solar, like net energy metering, shifts costs to non-solar customers. But the evidence is on their side.

Last December, Stanford public policy analysts published a report about a failed piece of shared renewables legislation, SB 843. Pacific Gas & Electric claimed that the bill would shift US$4 billion in statewide costs from participating to nonparticipating customers over its life – US$1.7 billion for its customers.

“The primary argument made against community solar, particularly by the utilities, is that proposed rate structures create an unfair, and often regressive, cost shift,” the authors wrote in Analysis of Community Solar Policy: Developments in the State of California.

But, they concluded: “There should be very little, if any, cost shift to other utility customers under the legislation… any cost shift is substantially less than that under the status quo of net energy metering.”

PG&E and Southern California Edison, the state's third investor-owned utility, have yet to follow SDG&E's lead.

But SEPA representatives told webinar participants last week that there are advantages of community solar for large utilities.

Mike Taylor, director of research at SEPA, said: “There are many utilities, particularly in the west that have taken community solar to heart and have a managed programme of their own. Why would utilities want to go through a community solar programme? What's their elevator pitch to an executive?

“Utilities want to stay proactively engaged with their customers, who are asking about solar – utilities may want to stay in that game and offer some choice. Community solar offers some more economic value to the customer.

“It can be more cost effective than distributed projects, you can gain some economies of scale, you can capitalise on some tax benefits that maybe a homeowner cannot … or perhaps these projects can be cheaper than offering a rebate programme for on site [rooftop] solar.”

But utilities have to take care to design the project appropriately for their market and territory.

“If a utility in Kansas were to start up a programme, odds are this is a big relative development to that local market, whereas a community programme in Arizona or California, this might be a smaller piece, relative to that market.

“Utilities can get caught by this if they're not careful. Customers have choices now, they can put solar on their roof, they can contract with third parties, they could theoretically buy renewable energy credits of some kind, but those dollar per kilowatt hour costs should be competitive with the other options.

“There are some utilities that are going back to their project and saying prices have changed in the market and our customers are going to other options and not signing up as fast as we thought they would.”

The SolarShares programme run by Sacramento Municipal Utility District (SMUD) is a popular 1MW project operated through a power purchase agreement with a developer.

SMUD has 700 customers signed up, with a waiting list of around 60 customers at any one time, said Bob Gibson, VP of education and outreach SEPA – whereas Trico's Electric Sunwatts in Arizona is struggling with competition from third-party finance options, he said.

Tax and securities issues for community solar are also a thorny regulatory issue yet to be addressed, said Gibson.

“One utility said it's like trying to do a Rubik's cube: you figure out the security side, and you turn it over and you try to figure out the tax side. You turn it back over and you've messed up the security side.”

“People like solar and the utility can play a really useful role in bringing solar into a community. But you do have to deal with some issues in terms of how to take advantage of the tax incentives. That can really change the cost of the programme. To take advantage of the tax code, the system has to be located on your property.”

However, a cooperative in Tennessee has structured its community solar as a limited partnership, while coops have formed limited liability companies to create a taxable subsidiary, he added.

A medium-term additional benefit for consumers of community solar may arise if the developer flips the project back to a non-profit utility after five to six years of depreciation.

“We've seen some prices as low as 5c-6c per kWh once the tax depreciation and tax advantages have been taken by an entity that has that tax appetite. For those who are subscribing this is a resource for the future and many years out that would be a hedge.”

Ultimately, one of the biggest appeals of community solar is the value proposition and that does not always come down to the cheapest rate: communities want power sourced as locally as possible. Green pricing failed to gain mass appeal 10 years ago because consumers were being sold ‘clean power’ generated by wind two states away.

“A locally owned resource that is a new and clean resource like solar, having it in the community does make a difference,” said Gibson.

26 January 2022
Join this free webinar for our analysis of the growth of N-Type technology including; new capacity expansions and production output. We'll also be looking at the global manufacturing footprint with forecasts on how much product will be made outside of China this year and which companies are driving technology change across the crystalline silicon value chain.
23 February 2022
Held annually since 2016, the Energy Storage Summit Europe is the place to be for senior stakeholders in the European storage industry. Designed to accelerate deployment of storage, we examine evolving chemistries, business models, project design, revenue stacks and use cases for storage. The 2022 edition will include exclusive content around longer duration solutions, energy strategies for wide-scale deployment of EVs and "EnTech", the event which sits at the intersection of digitisation, decentralisation and decarbonation of the power system. Come to meet TSOs, DSOs, Utilities, Developers, Investors and Lenders and leave with new contacts, partners and a wealth of information.
7 March 2022
Take your chance to join the most powerful platform in the MENA region. Middle East Energy (MEE), Intersolar, and ees, the leading energy exhibitions are joining hands to co-deliver an outstanding renewables and energy storage event at Middle East Energy 2021. Renewables and energy storage at MEE is the largest gathering of solar and renewable energy industry professionals in the Middle East & Africa, offering the most effective trade focused platform to international manufacturers and distributors looking to meet regional buyers.
8 March 2022
As Solar Finance & Investment enters its ninth year, we sit on the cusp of a new power market with solar at its heart. The 2022 edition of the event will build on our years of expertise and relationships to bring investors and lenders together with top developers. Connect with leaders in the field and use exclusive insights to drive investment and development decisions for the future. Meet new and existing project partners at the largest gathering of European solar investors and lenders.
23 March 2022
When it comes to storage, the US market exceeded a gigawatt of advanced energy storage installations (weighted towards lithium ion) at 1.46 GW, more than the previous six years in total! An exponential growth rate could see the market hit 7.5 GW p.a. by 2025. The summit will provide a wealth of content around this vital piece in the US power puzzle, with sessions dedicated to explore how companies are making money from batteries, the latest chemistries and their applications as they apply to different use-cases. We ask how investors can match ESG criteria to batteries and we will bring case studies of successful deployment and project execution onto the stage to examine how you can ensure your own projects are successful.
29 March 2022
Now in its 10th sell-out year, Large Scale Solar returns to Lisbon in 2022. We are excited to gather together face-to-face with the European solar industry as we provide unique and exclusive access to a powerful selection of the market's key stakeholders. Join this elite summit to find out how the market is maturing, which new markets are becoming more exciting, how technology is evolving and who's driving the market forward into the 2020s. Always senior, packed with developers, EPCs, utilities and investors this is the event for companies serious about European solar PV.

Read Next

January 16, 2022
The US Government has appealed against the reinstatement of an exemption from Section 201 tariffs for bifacial modules.
January 14, 2022
The US Department of Energy (DOE) has launched a “Building a Better Grid” initiative to catalyse the development of “new and upgraded high-capacity electric transmission lines” across the US under President Joe Biden’s US$1 trillion Bipartisan Infrastructure Law.
January 14, 2022
Module manufacturer and energy solutions company Q CELLS has entered into a strategic partnership with development and financing firm Kendall Sustainable Infrastructure (KSI) to collaborate on project co-development and financing.
PV Tech Premium
January 14, 2022
Raising more than US$1 billion in equity capital in the past year, US independent power producer (IPP) Silicon Ranch is looking to expand its model of developing, owning and operating large-scale PV plants while maintaining a strategy of co-locating projects with regenerative agriculture.
January 14, 2022
SMA Solar has cut its earnings forecast for the year by more than half pending a contract issue affecting its operations and maintenance business.  
January 14, 2022
Changzhou Better Film plans to invest RMB800 million (US$125 million) into establishing 20GW of ethylene vinyl acetate (EVA) production in the Chinese city of Chuzhou.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
January 26, 2022
Free Webinar
Solar Media Events
February 23, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 8, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 23, 2022
Austin, Texas, USA
Solar Media Events
March 29, 2022
Lisbon, Portugal