Landmark Indian solar case a ‘waste of time’: SunBorne MD

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Email

A landmark case in the Indian state of Gujarat is wasting the solar sector’s resources and creating unnecessary uncertainty, according to the managing director of SunBorne Energy.

The company is one of five taken to the Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission (GERC) by Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd. (GUVNL), a state-owned distributor that is looking to cut the rate it pays for electricity from 88 solar projects by 28%.

This article requires Premium SubscriptionBasic (FREE) Subscription

Try Premium for just $1

  • Full premium access for the first month at only $1
  • Converts to an annual rate after 30 days unless cancelled
  • Cancel anytime during the trial period

Premium Benefits

  • Expert industry analysis and interviews
  • Digital access to PV Tech Power journal
  • Exclusive event discounts

Or get the full Premium subscription right away

Or continue reading this article for free

The petition claims the solar developers are enjoying “windfall profits”. An initial hearing took place on Tuesday (23 July) where lawyers representing the companies involved called for the petition to be thrown out.

James Abraham, managing director of SunBorne Energy, told PV-Tech that the companies were making “good not great profits” and warned the petition would have serious consequences if it gained traction.

“Overall this entire case is a precedent setting one,” Abraham said. “The most important issue is whether this calls into question any contracts. If the regulators honour the petition and they start examining contracts, the risk is that anyone can then refute a signed agreement and go to the regulator based on this precedent. That is why, as I listened to what they said yesterday, the regulator was being very, very careful even to admit the petition. This is by no means closed out yet.”

Abraham said the majority of the parties were confident that the petition would not proceed.

“If you look at most of the investors, everyone is confident about how this is going to turn out. It’s an incredible waste of time and money and it creates uncertainty.

Should things go against SunBorne and its peers, the result could be severe. Gujarat is home to more than half of India’s solar power capacity.

“If they admit the petition and do a tariff reduction across the board, that is the worst case situation. That would allow any contract to be opened and on the regulators orders, be challenged. That would create the worst situation for the industry. It would call into question the sanctity of contracts. How do you then make investments based on that?”

GUVNL claims that the rate it has agreed to pay developers over a 25-year period is too high but Abraham raised question marks about its calculations.

“In the petition that the distribution company made it cited ten examples where developers were making windfall profits. That’s ten out of 88 so the sample size is small and of those ten, three were represented at the hearing and said the data was wrong.

“I think the starting point, the basis on which they are making these assertions, is itself called into question. Certainly if you look at the data across the board, none of the developments were at the capital costs that GUVNL had suggested,” claimed Abraham.

The alternative to an across the board tariff cut would be a case-by-case examination by the regulator of each of the 88 projects.

“If they do look at this on a project by project basis I’m not worried because every project, certainly ours, will be able to show there is no such thing as windfall gains. Everybody is making good but not great profits and developing renewable power in the process.”

The second half of the hearing will take place on 5 August with GUVNL given the chance to respond to the calls for dismissal raised by the developers.

Read Next

September 18, 2025
CERC is finalising guidelines for virtual power purchase agreements (vPPAs) to unlock financing for over 40GW of uncontracted renewable capacity.
September 18, 2025
The capacity of virtual power plants in operation in North America has reached 37.5GW, a 13.7% year-on-year growth, according to Wood Mackenzie.
September 18, 2025
The Canadian Renewable Energy Association (CanREA) has forecast that Canada will add between 17GW and 26GW of solar PV over the next decade.
September 18, 2025
Researchers have called for enhanced international standards to detect ultraviolet-induced degradation (UVID) in PV modules after identifying “severe” levels of the problem in operational n-type panels.             
September 18, 2025
Indian PV makers have welcomed the government’s plan to add solar wafers to its ALMM List-III from June 2028.
September 17, 2025
US renewables developer Longroad Energy has reached financial close for its 400MW 1000 Mile solar project in the US state of Texas.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
September 30, 2025
Seattle, USA
Solar Media Events
October 1, 2025
London, UK
Solar Media Events
October 2, 2025
London,UK
Solar Media Events
October 7, 2025
Manila, Philippines
Solar Media Events
October 7, 2025
San Francisco Bay Area, USA