PV Talk: How COP21 could spur a new era of global collaboration on solar R&D


Earlier this year, a group of leading scientists and economists published a report making the case for a “Global Apollo programme” to combat climate change. At the heart of their vision was an internationally coordinated programme of research and development on clean energy technologies such as solar, storage and grid management. The aim: to make the cost of new base-load power from renewable sources cheaper than that of coal in all parts of the world by 2025.

As part of our coverage in the run-up to the COP21 talks in Paris later this year, PV Tech spoke to Sir David King, the UK’s former chief scientific advisor and one of the lead authors of the Apollo report. He is currently the UK foreign secretary's permanent special representative for climate change. Under discussion was how the Global Apollo Programme would operate and how he hoped Paris would help secure the necessary political buy-in for the initiative.

Sir David King on the transition to clean energy:

PV Tech: Your report has won some high profile backers, including Sir David Attenborough and many others. What traction has it gained so far at a political level?

Sir David King: The Apollo programme was published by a group of authors outside government in June. The follow-through was on June 8th, the G7 heads of government communiqué; this included the statement that got a lot of media attention, which is decarbonise the world’s economy this century. The second part of the statement was a major thrust in R&D demonstration in renewable energy technology so that we can roll out cheap energy around the world. So that's got the blessing of the G7 heads of government – they've asked for their energy ministers to report back to the next meeting of the G7, which will be next year, when the Japanese will be in the presidency. So it's rolling. And it's rolling in another sense because of Paris. And so there's a useful means of accelerating the process because everyone's trying to get things in before Paris.

PV Tech: What is the idea behind the programme?
Sir David King: The idea of the programme as set out there, but this isn't established with any certainty in the government forum, is that there would be a consortium of countries that would set up a technology roadmap committee, and the technology committee would sort out what research needs to be done to de-risk the energy sector so that the private sector, in the slipstream of this money, can get into the marketplace with all of the sectors' requirements, including still-cheaper photovoltaics, still-cheaper renewable primary sources, storage and smart grids. So that's really the focus of the programme.

PV Tech: You’ve stated publicly before that you think solar offers humanity the best chance of weaning itself off fossil fuels. How much focus is there on solar in the Apollo programme?
Sir David King: The focus isn't only on solar – it's renewables; we are looking at solar, wind, geothermal, wave – all of the above. Farming energy from all of those natural sources is really what we're on about. If you come to solar, we know the most dramatic fall in installation costs have occurred in the solar photovoltaic regime. And this is heavily driven by European Union feed-in tariffs. So creating competitive markets through feed-in tariffs has enabled solar to come into the marketplace and battle against maturer technologies, which is what the fossil fuel technologies are.

But because that has been so successful, and the prices have come down so rapidly – US$50 down to half a dollar a watt, it means that even without subsidies, installation costs of solar PV for sunny regions has become very competitive. But it is true the sun doesn't shine anywhere in the world at night, so energy storage and smart grids have become a part of rolling out base-load electricity from that source. And energy storage and smart grids got no benefits from feed-in tariffs.

PV Tech: What's the process now for getting your programme adopted?
Sir David King: It’s already with the right people – it’s got the attention of the heads of government; that was the whole point of taking it through the G7. I think that all I can say at this stage is watch out for announcements. The IEA [International Energy Agency] has an energy ministerial meeting coming up in November, there’s a G20 meeting in late November; these are all opportunities for heads of government and ministers of energy to develop the elements of the programme into something before Paris.

PV Tech: How would the funding and coordination work at an international level?
Sir David King: Nobody is talking about creating another bucket of money. So it’s not like European framework money that sits in Brussels and then countries bid into it. Your research scientists are funded by your government. Now, there will be collaborations, from one country to another, from one research group to another. But that is all focused on delivering the mission-oriented programme of work set out by a roadmap committee.

PV Tech: The Apollo programme report states that decarbonising the global economy is a technological challenge, it’s also political, and on that front we’ve seen political support for renewables go into reverse in places like the UK. What is your view on cuts to support for renewables in the UK and other places where we’ve seen this happen?
Sir David King: I think the secretary of state’s going to make an announcement on that [cuts to the UK FiTs]. Let me make a general point on tariffs. You introduce feed-in tariffs when the price is US$50 per watt, because otherwise no one will put photovoltaics on their roof. So you have to subsidise to compete with the fossil fuel-based technology. When the price comes down to half a dollar a watt, there’s no longer going to be a market then for feed-in tariffs; governments would be wrong to do subsidies where they’re not needed. What we are talking about through the G7 programme is an alternative to subsidies. It’s looking at public funding going into R, D&D [research, development and demonstration] so as to de-risk for the private sector. That’s not a subsidy process.

PV Tech: What in your view is going to happen in Paris in December?
Sir David King: I think there’s going to be an agreement. I think there are difficulties in reaching an agreement, and the biggest difficulty is international finance, the flow of funds from the developed to the developing world, particularly to the poorest.

The [other] issue is whether countries like India and Brazil, who’ve previously been quite difficult to negotiate with, will deliver. My own view, having visited over 60 countries in the last two years, is that we will find alignment. So there’s going to be an agreement. But it is absolutely crucial that agreement includes reviewability – so the INDCs [intended nationally determined contributions] from each country are seen as the least effort required and that what we need to do is move on beyond that as technologies roll out, as it gets easier, so countries will be able to improve on their nationally determined contributions.

The international agreement in Paris is very important largely because of the momentum that it will generate. What happened after Copenhagen was a loss of momentum and a loss of appetite for action – so we need that agreement. But the actions that are happening on the ground are not really part of the agreement. It’s an umbrella under which we are all operating.

PV Tech: How confident are you that your vision of a world powered by clean energy is possible?
Sir David King: I don’t think it’s a possibility, it’s going to happen – we have to do it. So when the G7 heads of government announced they are going to decarbonise the world’s economy by the end of the century, they mean it. And I believe we have, frankly, no option.

To browse our coverage of the run-up to COP21 and the opportunities it offers solar, click here.

26 September 2022
The WCPEC is the world’s biggest platform for PV research and development, offering a unique possibility of international exchange by combining the three largest and most prominent international PV conferences: the European PV Solar Energy Conference (EU PVSEC), the Photovoltaic Specialists Conference (IEEE PVSC) and the International PV Science and Engineering Conference (PVSEC). In 2022, Europe has the honour to host the 8th World Conference on Photovoltaic Energy Conversion, interchanging the prestigious EU PVSEC for this year, that is being held annually for more than 40 years. After being in place for more than a quarter of a century, the WCPEC, being held every four years, is firmly established among the global PV community as THE event for the greatest minds and experts in various PV sectors to meet and discuss, to exchange and network! The conference programme is coordinated by the European Commission Joint Research Centre.
27 September 2022
The demand for rooftop solar PV is soaring, driven by falling costs of the technology against energy crises that are gripping countries globally. But while an increasing number of households turn to solar to generate their own electricity, there is now a need for more specialist equipment, technologies and services to ensure the solar transition can reach as many customers as possible. Delivering these is now a major challenge for rooftop solar installers. This webinar will analyse the characteristics of the rooftop solar market, discussing how the products, logistics, installation and servicing of solar systems has evolved in line with consumer demands.
4 October 2022
Solar & Storage Finance USA, the only event that connects developers to capital and capital to solar and storage projects, will be back in November 2022.
11 October 2022
RE+ Florida returns in 2022. Solar & Energy Storage Florida is now RE+ Florida! This premier event for the Sunshine State will return October 11-12, 2022 in Miami.
11 October 2022
PV CellTech Extra will be held as a series of live webinars and on-demand sessions on 11-13 October 2022. We'll be taking a slightly further forward-looking view at the technologies and roadmaps for new cell architectures set to dominate mass production during 2023-2025 with special emphasis on the potential timelines for technologies beyond the single-junction cell design, including perovskite and hybrid concepts.
13 October 2022
The 2022 ACORE Grid Forum is a one-day event that convenes regulators, renewable, storage and transmission companies, and other leading grid experts in Washington, D.C. Speakers will examine the roles of administrative orders and actions, infrastructure policy, regional and state developments, and private sector strategies on the path to a carbon-free grid.

Read Next

September 23, 2022
India’s government has approved the second round of the production-linked incentive (PLI) scheme to incentivise domestic solar PV module manufacturing.
PV Tech Premium
September 23, 2022
Plans for a temporary revenue cap on solar PV assets across the European Union (EU) could dent investor confidence in renewables, experts have warned, amid concerns that individual member states may be able to set lower caps specific to different technologies.
September 23, 2022
Solar accounted for half of all global power generating capacity added last year, with 182GW deployed, a 25% increase on 2020, according to a report from BloombergNEF (BNEF).
PV Tech Premium
September 23, 2022
Community solar in the US is projected to grow substantially over the next decade and represents a means of expanding access to underserved communities who are being left out of the energy transition. Sean Rai-Roche explores the drivers of community solar and what obstacles need to be overcome to support its rollout.
September 22, 2022
The RE+ tradeshow has been full of hope, excitement but also short-term questions as the industry considers the significance of the IRA.
PV Tech Premium
September 22, 2022
The war in Ukraine, approaching its eighth month, is having an extremely detrimental effect on the country's solar sector.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
September 27, 2022
15:30 AEST (UTC +10)
Solar Media Events
October 4, 2022
New York, USA
On-Demand Webinars, Solar Media Events
October 11, 2022
Virtual event
Upcoming Webinars
October 18, 2022
10am (EDT) / 4pm (CEST)