FBR polysilicon technology – promise or hype?

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on reddit
Reddit
Share on email
Email

The recent announcement by US manufacturer REC Silicon that it would establish a new polysilicon plant with an annual production capacity of 19,000 metric tons (MT) has highlighted an upcoming trend in the polysilicon industry: the rise of fluidised bed reactor (FBR) technology.

FBR granules. Image: REC Silicon

Like REC, China-based GCL-Poly, the world's largest polysilicon manufacturer, and SMP, a joint venture between US producer MEMC (now Sunedison) and Samsung Fine Chemicals in South Korea, are also building polysilicon plants using FBR technology with monosilane as the feed gas.

In an FBR, monosilane (silane for short) is injected through nozzles at the bottom of the reactor to form a fluidised bed that carries silicon seed particles fed from above. Silicon deposits from the silane on the seed particles until they have grown to larger granules, which can then be withdrawn from the reactor continuously.

A silane FBR needs only 10% of the electricity that a conventional rod reactor in the established Siemens process consumes. Using silane as feed gas also avoids the energy-intensive off-gas recovery in the Siemens process, which is based on trichlorosilane.

Great potential – but how much of it is realistic?

Hence, REC, GCL-Poly and Sunedison for example promise cash production costs (manufacturing costs without depreciation) of less than US$10/kg for their future FBR polysilicon plants. That would be a substantial gain over the US$14 to 15/kg benchmark of the best incumbent polysilicon manufacturers using the Siemens process.

Moreover, the granular form factor provides additional advantages for making silicon ingots, the next step in the value chain. Mixing polysilicon granules from an FBR with chunks from a Siemens-type rod reactor can shorten the time to fill a crucible by 40% and increase the charge weight by 30%.

The particular value of granules, however, lies in their suitability to continuously recharge single crystal pullers working with the Czochralski (Cz) process. FBR could, therefore, push continuous Cz technology – another innovation that promises both better quality of crystal and a substantial cost reduction over the expensive batch Cz process.

The 2013 edition of the International Technology Roadmap for Photovoltaics (ITRPV), which was prepared by experts from leading PV manufacturers, projects that the FBR process will reach a share of 30% in polysilicon production by 2017, thus nearly quadrupling its 2012 share of 8% within just five years. No doubt, FBR technology offers great potential. But doesn’t all this sound a little bit too good to be true?

Similarities and dissimilarities to the UMG silicon hype

At his point, it might be helpful to take a view back to another contender of the dominant Siemens process: upgraded metallurgical-grade (UMG) silicon.

Its proponents talked pretty big at the peak of the polysilicon shortage in 2007/2008. Eicke Weber, director of the Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems in Freiburg, Germany and co-founder of the Californian UMG solar cell manufacturer Calisolar (now Silicor Materials), forecast that UMG silicon could reach a market share of up to 50% (yes: fifty percent) in crystalline solar cells by 2015. Timminco, a Canadian UMG silicon producer now defunct, promised manufacturing costs of C$12/kg (approx. US$11.30/kg then) for 2008.

Both predictions burst like a bubble. UMG silicon technology was not mature yet and the promises were greatly exaggerated. Today the approach still suffers from the bad image it earned at that time with little traction gained.

Could FBR then end up as just another three-letter acronym for a technology that has been overhyped? The answer is not simply yes or no. Unlike UMG, FBR technology has already been proven in commercial production for quite some time:

-MEMC’s 4,200MT plant in Pasadena, Texas (USA) has been running for more than 26 years. It is able to produce electronic-grade material; approximately 60% of its output is used for semiconductor wafers. The plant is at a disadvantage mainly because of its expensive silane manufacturing process via the reduction of silicon tetrafluoride.

-REC Silicon’s FBR plant in Moses Lake, Washington (USA) has been at full steam for four years now and has reached an annual capacity of more than 16,000MT. The plant is quasi MEMC’s opposite: while it has demonstrated low cash costs of US$12/kg, its output is only solar grade with a high metal content. Electronic-grade material will come from REC’s next reactor generation (‘FBR B’), which has been tested on pilot scale for two years.

Electronic-grade purity and upscaling are challenges

There are two basic challenges to the promise of FBR. The first one is: can the technology really reach silicon purity close to or at electronic-grade level at cash costs below US$10/kg? The future will tell us. The second relates to up-scaling. Silicon deposition in an FBR is not easy to control; as the fluid dynamic changes with size, the reactor cannot simply be scaled up one to one from pilot to industrial scale.

SMP, the Samsung/Sunedison joint venture, will use high-pressure reactors which Sunedison claims to be six times more productive than MEMC’s older FBR generation in Pasadena. With such a technology leap, teething problems are bound to occur. It is thus not surprising that both SMP and GCL-Poly have already experienced delays with their FBR projects:

The start-up of SMP's 10,000MT FBR plant was originally announced for May 2013. In July 2013, however, the explosion of a water tank during a stress test killed three employees. Ramp-up of the plant was first postponed to late 2013, then to early 2014; now it is slated for late this year.

After GCL-Poly developed its own FBR technology in record time, it planned to bring the first 10,000 MT phase of its new FBR plant on stream in the first quarter of 2014. Meanwhile, the commissioning has been pushed back to the second half of this year as well.

In light of these facts, the ITRPV forecast of a 30% market share for FBR in 2017 does not appear realistic. Even if SMP, GCL-Poly and REC Silicon all have successfully ramped up their new plants by then, the share will at best double from 8% in 2012 to 16% in 2017. Potential other FBR projects will not be completed overnight.

Risk for REC Silicon’s joint venture in China

As REC Silicon does not have sufficient funds to expand its FBR plant in Moses Lake on its own, it is taking a route very similar to the asset-light approach of Sunedison: saving capital expenditure through a joint venture – in this case with Shaanxi Non-Ferrous Tianhong New Energy in China – and financing its equity share in the joint venture through revenues from licensing fees.

There were early indications that REC Silicon would choose a Chinese partner. Already in May 2012, at the 6th SNEC PV Power Expo in Shanghai, CEO Tore Torvund outlined the advantages of a location in China. The new FBR plant will benefit from low labour and raw material costs and allow REC to produce close to its customers in the world's largest market for polysilicon. Thus, the company will also avoid heavy punitive duties imposed on polysilicon imports from the United States.

All these advantages come at a price, however. China does not have a good reputation for protecting intellectual property although the situation is said to have improved in recent years. There remains a risk for REC that its FBR know-how will leak out over time. We will see what happens when the first employees leave the joint venture and take their knowledge to another place.

19 July 2022
As New South Wales is gearing up to become a renewable energy superpower, an exciting clean energy event is coming to Sydney. Energy Next is a free-to-attend industry event focusing on the latest renewable energy and energy management technologies, which will be held from 19-20 July 2022 at the ICC Sydney in Darling Harbour. Organised by the same people behind the country’s largest clean energy event, All-Energy Australia, Energy Next will bring a quality exhibition and technical session series to NSW. Energy Next will also host the Clean Energy Council’s Solar Masterclass with a program developed for solar designers and installers. Across two days, Energy Next will provide an extensive exhibition, workshops and networking opportunities for those working in the renewable energy industry to meet with leading suppliers, discover the latest technologies and gain an understanding of how to successfully launch new clean energy projects.
21 July 2022
The rooftop solar PV market is set for significant growth, but installers are being held back by complicated design software that is slow, cumbersome and fails to take into account rooftop shading, module compatibility and energy storage. Huawei’s SmartDesign 2.0 is a web-based PV and energy storage system tool that promises to solve all of those issues, and much more. This webinar will provide a live demonstration of the SmartDeisgn 2.0 tool, showing how installers can quickly complete Huawei PV & ESS system designs and assemble a professional report with 3D site view for potential customers, streamlining the design and sales service.
23 August 2022
Intersolar South America, South America’s largest exhibition and conference for the solar industry, takes place at the Expo Center Norte in São Paulo, Brazil, on August 23–25, 2022, and has a focus on the areas of photovoltaics, PV production and solar thermal technologies. At the accompanying Intersolar South America Conference, renowned experts shed light on hot topics in the solar industry. In 2021 – despite the Covid-19 pandemic – Intersolar South America welcomed more than 28,000 visitors and over 1,000 conference attendees over 3 days. 200+ providers showcased their products. Combining local and international expertise, Intersolar South America brings together the PV and solar thermal sector to discuss the current status and strategic trends for Latin American PV markets, as well as technology innovations and new business opportunities. Overall, distributed generation is still driving momentum in the Brazilian market.
6 September 2022
Intersolar Mexico sits at the cross-section of photovoltaics, solar heating & cooling technologies, and energy storage. The event serves as the industry’s go-to source for invaluable technology trends and premier B2B contacts in the promising Mexican solar market. From September 6–8, 2022 Intersolar Mexico together with the co-located The GREEN Expo® and Aquatech Mexico will take place in Centro Citibanamex, Mexico City.
19 September 2022
RE+ 2022 is the umbrella event that includes SPI, ESI, RE+ Power, and RE+ Infrastructure. As North America's largest renewable energy event, it's a catalyst for industry innovation that's supercharging business growth in the clean energy economy.
20 September 2022
From source to generation, from grid to consumer, the boundaries of the sector are blurring and this evolution is being shaped by established players, external disruptors, innovative start-ups and the increasingly engaged end-user. Enlit Asia is the unifying brand for POWERGEN Asia and Asian Utility Week, showcases expert knowledge, innovative solutions and foresight from industry leaders, coherent with Asian strategy to achieve a smooth transition towards a low carbon energy supply. This year, Enlit Asia will be co-located with Sustainable Energy Technology Asia (SETA) & Solar & Storage Asia (SSA).

Read Next

July 1, 2022
Hanwha Qcells’ power plant division Q ENERGY Europe has teamed up with newly rebranded Q ENERGY France to establish umbrella company Q ENERGY Solutions SE as it seeks to deepen its ties to the European market where it has a 12GW development portfolio.
July 1, 2022
The US Supreme Court has restricted the federal government’s authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from power plants in a ruling that critics have warned will hit renewables deployment and hobble the Biden administration’s climate agenda.
July 1, 2022
Off-grid pay-as-you-go solar provider Bboxx has partnered with telecommunications company Orange to launch a new solar mini-grid project to help accelerate clean energy access for households across the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).
PV Tech Premium
July 1, 2022
PV Tech Premium spoke with Cypress Creek Renewable Energy and AES Clean Energy to discuss the newly formed US Solar Buyer Consortium, its objectives, market challenges and the potential advantages it holds for US manufacturing and project development.
July 1, 2022
Energy management software company Cleartrace has secured US$20 million in a financing round to accelerate the growth of its platform.
June 30, 2022
Investor CleanCapital has acquired renewable energy developer BQ Energy, adding 300MW of late-stage solar development to its pipeline.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
October 4, 2022
New York, USA
Solar Media Events
October 11, 2022
Virtual event