German solar industry offered poisoned pill by Merkel’s government

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on reddit
Reddit
Share on email
Email

The German solar industry’s research and development efforts into advanced solar cell technology will be given a boost of €100 million, after Chancellor Angela Merkel’s cabinet approved plans, according to Reuters. The move was made, according to the report, to weaken resistance by members of the lower house of parliament (Bundesrat), particularly from eastern states such as Thuringia, Saxony and Saxony-Anhalt, to a proposed 16% extra solar feed-in tariff cut. There are a a significant number of PV manufacturers located in these regions, and many have openly opposed the FIT cut suggested by Merkel’s government.

Since the tariff cuts were proposed, the German government has reiterated that the country’s PV manufacturers and equipment and materials suppliers would need to retain a competitive position against lower-cost manufacturers in China and Taiwan by continued investments in R&D.

Indeed, in general terms a 10% improvement in c-Si cell conversion efficiency can translate into a 9% reduction in the cost per watt. The aim of the government is to boost R&D funding to enable German PV producers to keep ahead in the performance stakes by several technology cycles, negating the lower cost modules from China and Taiwan that in general have lower watt performance levels.

There are several fundamental problems with this strategy, not least the amount being offered, which we can only assume at this point will distributed over several years. Not only is €100 million insufficient to retain an industry technology leadership, it pales into insignificance when you look at the resources China is focusing on PV R&D and government willingness to support just Suntech and Trina Solar with loans from the China Development Bank of US$11.72 billion!

Of course these sums of money are not being spent on R&D alone but in continued capacity expansions, project finance for utility-scale solar projects, etc…However, leading Chinese producers are fully aware that they also need to close the performance gap with German producers and are continuing to purchase next-generation equipment from European suppliers that enable such advancements to be made.

This means that R&D spending in Germany–and Europe as whole, for that matter–would need to accelerate and maintain something like a three- to four-year performance advantage to clearly differentiate from Asian competitors. However, the performance advantage may have to be wider once the major Chinese producers start hitting 2GW and above manufacturing outputs, as scaling economies would see rapidly decreasing production costs.

That could be multiplied further should German manufacturers not keep in relative step with capacity expansions of overseas rivals as scale, plus performance is an essential part of the armoury required to remain competitive. Furthermore, R&D expenditure of PV equipment suppliers in Europe has traditionally been in the low single-digit range as a percentage of sales. In the semiconductor industry, equipment suppliers have consistently been required to spend in the 20% range to offer leading-edge tools and processes as well as productivity and yield improvements to remain competitive.

Significant changes to spending behaviour would be required across the supply chain to support German PV manufacturers. Far more attractive R&D tax credits would need to be in place compared to those benefits currently employed, to support greater R&D spending.
 
Perhaps the biggest problem actually relates to notion that focusing on R&D keeps German PV manufacturers actually manufacturing in Germany, while remaining competitive.

Looking at the semiconductor industry in Europe as an example, long-term R&D funding from the EU has not kept semiconductor manufacturing in Europe. Companies have both shifted a greater percentage of production to lower-cost regions and/or shifted leading-edge production to foundries based in Taiwan and become virtually fabless in operation or asset-lite or fab-lite in nature.

As technology advances increase in complexity and cost, the trend has been that more and more of the real R&D needs to done where the manufacturing occurs. The distance between the two operations impacts technology migration timescales as well as implementation costs, just to mention a few of the key aspects.

The result has been that much of the R&D funding from the EU has actually directly benefited Asian foundries as they not only get the manufacturing of advanced products and the jobs associated but their own R&D investments are less due to being indirectly subsidised by the EU funding!

The German PV industry has already seen its biggest cell producer Q-Cells close trailing-edge production lines in Germany and establish bigger and more advanced operations in Malaysia to retain cost competitiveness. They have even gone further by establishing foundry-like operations in an outsourcing deal for module assembly, also in Malaysia with Flextronics.

It can be assumed that Q-Cells would be a current beneficiary of Merkel’s millions offered in R&D, but what is the long-term return for the German government and its citizens?

Due to the drastic module price declines seen in 2009, many German distributors and larger installers have rushed to purchase nonbranded modules from Chinese producers under OEM contracts. Companies such as JA Solar and LDK Solar are rapidly expanding module production to the 1GW level and above to meet demand for OEM modules, with the majority of that business conveniently described by the producers as coming from Europe. But the reality is that much of this product demand is coming from Germany.

Ironically, the proposed cuts to the tariff due in July will only increase the rate of adoption of such modules, something that R&D funding on its own will not stop. Indeed, it also shrinks the available market for ‘Made in Germany’ modules in the country, as the downstream supply chain needs to compete against low-cost Chinese-branded products.

‘Made in Germany’ modules may not simply disappear but they are already becoming a smaller percentage of the installations in the country. Over time that means less manufacturing capacity expansions in Germany and less need for the German government to fund R&D as the returns in the form of manufacturing jobs diminish.

This is the current state of affairs in respect to the semiconductor industry in Europe and its fight to obtain renewed R&D funding from the EU. Politicians simply don’t like giving money away when the potential job generation is low, doubtful, or simply nonexistent. Big money allocation requires big job number generation.

The German PV industry is therefore asking for trouble down the road should the R&D funds not deliver the job creation and a likely result that future needed funding is drastically reduced or stopped altogether.

Merkel’s millions may well be viewed as a form of inducement to politicians in the Bundesrat to agree to tariff cuts, but surely this is actually a poison pill for those politicians with stakes in the PV industry and German PV industry as a whole?

25 May 2022
Transforming the Canadian energy market. Solar & Storage Canada will focus on fostering and expanding the solar and energy storage market in Canada. Co-located with f-cell Canada.
7 June 2022
The Renewable Energy Trading Summit is the only event in Europe dedicated to renewable energy trading and will bring together renewable power asset owners, investors, exchanges, intermediaries and large energy buyers to discover the future of power sales. This unique event is designed specifically for the most senior players and will provide an excellent forum for business deals, networking and learning. The energy transition is gathering pace with renewable energy attracting increasing sums of capital each year. Solar and wind deployment is increasing annually and governments are ever-more reliant on the renewables sector to stimulate moribund economies. Retirement of fossil fuel assets continues in the background. However, without subsidies and uncertainty around PPAs, renewable asset owners are heading into the wholesale markets to trade power but are they ready for the volatility in revenue this will entail?
9 June 2022
The proliferation of solar PV and other renewables is a cornerstone of the emerging new power system and, as a result, the solar industry has entered its fastest-growth period. This has become typified by surging demand for high-power PV modules that both produce more power and are more efficient than their predecessors. Providing a significant boost to power outputs, large-format modules have become a popular choice for customers the world over. Outdoor testing of modules is now providing empirical evidence of the benefits large-format modules produce, providing a crucial benchmark and invaluable data for customers to evaluate their module selection and procurement processes. In this PV Tech webinar, experts from TÜV Rheinland, CPVT and Trina Solar will discuss how to ensure science based and precision testing under field conditions, how empirical data is collected and analysed during TÜV Rheinland and CPVT’s outdoor testing, the empirical data behind a 670W module’s ultra-high power, and more.
14 June 2022
Join us in Napa to unlock the key to reliable PV module supply to the U.S. market in 2022 & 2023. We'll also be gathering the main players in the US solar market for some wine tasting!
15 June 2022
Consumers are turning to residential renewables in significant numbers, driven by a desire to be environmentally conscious and a wave of high power prices. But turning green requires easy-to-use and, above all, safe technologies that meet expectations. Huawei is committed to building efficient, safe, reliable and grid-supporting smart PV plants that also provide smart services to consumers, and its Residential Solution has been tailored to meet consumer demand. This webinar will demonstrate the full suite of technologies offered within the Huawei Residential Solution, including a smart energy controller, smart AC charger, and AI-powered energy storage solution, and detail how it can place power back in the consumer’s hands.
22 June 2022
The 11th edition of the Large Scale Solar Summit is coming to the US after 10 sell-out years in Europe! Designed as a meeting place for deal-making, we will not only discuss the most up to date topics and technologies but will also provide varied networking platforms so that developers, EPCs, manufacturers, asset owners, and investors can connect with possible clients and partners. In a year expected to break records for the solar market, join us in Texas to meet with the top players in the industry and expand your network as business booms.

Read Next

May 25, 2022
Module price increases, higher raw material costs and logistical challenges will pull down the return on equity (ROE) for 25GW of India solar projects, with 5GW of those at high risk given when they submitted their bids.
May 25, 2022
Supply chain woes, spiralling energy prices and the COVID-19 pandemic have reversed the downward trend in average business interruption (BI) claims for renewables developers, with sector-wide average business downtime days up by 38% on 2016.  
May 25, 2022
TotalEnergies has made its “largest investment in US renewables” to date, acquiring a stake in developer Clearway Energy.
May 25, 2022
Shell has tasked renewables monitoring and control firm Inaccess to optimise a 100MW solar-wind hybrid project in the Netherlands.
May 24, 2022
French renewable energy company Compagnie Nationale du Rhône (CNR) has set up a new subsidiary that will focus on the development of solar installations in the Rhône valley area of France.
May 24, 2022
Nextracker will supply 1.5GW of its solar trackers to US independent power producer (IPP) Silicon Ranch as part of a new agreement between the companies.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
June 7, 2022
Leonardo Royal London City, London, UK
Solar Media Events
June 14, 2022
Napa, USA
Solar Media Events
June 22, 2022
Sheraton Austin Hotel at the Capitol, Austin, Texas