Is overcapacity over-hyped?

July 20, 2009
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Email

Take any market research firm’s data on end-user demand for solar modules and compare that with manufacturing supply and there is a massive gap to the negative, pushing prices lower from bare wafers to modules. Last week, Q-Cells binned its forecast for revenue for 2009, citing continued lack of demand and falling prices due to the competitive landscape caused by overcapacity.

However, FiT’s, stimulus packages and growing global awareness of the need for PV suggests that in a few years, these current hard times will be a thing of the past.

This article requires Premium SubscriptionBasic (FREE) Subscription

Try Premium for just $1

  • Full premium access for the first month at only $1
  • Converts to an annual rate after 30 days unless cancelled
  • Cancel anytime during the trial period

Premium Benefits

  • Expert industry analysis and interviews
  • Digital access to PV Tech Power journal
  • Exclusive event discounts

Or get the full Premium subscription right away

Or continue reading this article for free

The problem is, which year over the next few will demand catch up with supply? What should PV manufacturers do to survive until that time in the near future that enables companies to make a profit and build businesses for the future? Worse is the view that overcapacity is here to stay so PV manufacturers need to react now and fast, otherwise there will be no future?

The continued module price declines and extreme competitive environment will continue while the overcapacity scenario continues. The problem is that the market research firms and the industry at large do not have detailed and accurate data available as to how much nominal capacity actually exists and what the current factory utilization rates actually are.

This could result in a warped perspective of real supply overhang compared to educated probable overhang. Importantly, it often takes ‘nominal’ capacity as given (overinflated) and actual capacity (underestimated) but also leaves gaps caused by the fast paced dynamics of an industry growing and shrinking too fast to comprehensively characterise in ‘real-time.’ Lags in real-time data grow when the industry dynamics change so fast.

Then there is the role of the trade press and general media commentary on these issues that can perpetuate, overexaggerate or incorrectly report on the real situation at hand. The media in general will often be lambasted for doom and gloom industry perspectives and ridiculed (trade press) when a rosy picture is reported when darkness still surrounds many in the world of manufacturing reality.

Attending Intersolar North America last week, I had a few opportunities to discuss with senior PV manufacturing executives and industry analysts the issues surrounding overcapacity data and what happens to that overcapacity in a period of fast-changing dynamics.

My hypothesis was based on a view that there is a significant amount of nominal capacity in place that is fast becoming redundant due to the continuing rapid module price declines, making much of this capacity uncompetitive. This capacity, wherever it may be, has already been affected, forcing ‘much’ to be idled. However, when supply and demand reach a new balanced state that capacity will not come back on stream because it’s old technology, unable to compete at the significantly lower price levels that are then the norm.

This means that overcapacity figures are now and will continue to be overinflated until it can be verified such capacity should be removed from the nominal capacity models.

Only after the real return to supply/demand balance will it then be realised and covered and confirmed by the media. This would be too late for many and barely in time for others!

I am happy to report that my picture of supply and demand dynamics was not scorned by those I had time to discuss it with. Not surprisingly, the discussions led to when the balance would return, either later than I was projecting or sooner.

The challenge for all of us was the realization that without the real detailed capacity data we all were pontificating on, it was a position that wouldn’t hold up in a court of law.

My conclusion was that we obviously need better data but also better modelling and also a better understanding of what the true impact is on manufacturing when confronted with rapid and potentially long-periods of price declines whether gradual or fast paced. This of course should be taken in light of the real demand, another Pandora’s Box that needs to be opened and debated, not least modelled better than it currently is!

Is it a simple stupid moment?

It’s certainly a very difficult and incredibly complex situation for the industry to be in and now requires some smart minds to get to grips with the real problem. That’s not going to come from the media but I genuinely don’t believe it can just be left up to the market analyst either, over to you!

Read Next

Premium
October 17, 2025
According to Ronak Maheshwari of CRC-IB, there has been a struggle for US renewable power projects to secure necessary equity .
October 17, 2025
Norwegian renewable energy firm Scatec has signed lease agreements for 64MW of solar PV and 10MWh of energy storage capacity in Liberia and Sierra Leone.
October 17, 2025
A group of over 20 US states are suing the Trump administration for the cancellation of the US$7 billion Solar For All Scheme.
October 16, 2025
Masdar and Turkey have entered the final stage of US$1 billion agreement to develop the 1.1GW plant in Bor, Niğde Province, central Turkey.
October 16, 2025
T1 Energy and Nextracker have agreed to use the latter’s steel module frames at the former’s new 5GW module manufacturing facility in Dallas.
October 16, 2025
US utility-scale solar additions grew by 56% in 2024, reaching 30GW from 2023’s 19GW and representing over 54% of all new electricity generation capacity added in the country last year.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
October 21, 2025
New York, USA
Solar Media Events
November 25, 2025
Warsaw, Poland
Solar Media Events
December 2, 2025
Málaga, Spain
Solar Media Events
February 3, 2026
London, UK