Study exposes ‘major flaws’ in case against Chinese solar duties

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

A report commissioned by the group lobbying for trade duties on Chinese solar products has described claims made in an earlier study that tariffs would cost the European solar industry €27.8 billion as “highly questionable”.

The report, by accountancy firm PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) and commissioned by EU Prosun, said the Prognos study, commissioned by the Alliance for Affordable Solar Energy (AFASE) in February, contains major flaws in methodology and content.

PwC said it analysed the Prognos study according European Commission guidelines on evidence used in competition proceedings.

It concluded that the Prognos study used a questionable methodology that was inconsistent with theseguidelines. “This study should be dismissed and not taken into consideration by the European Commission, European Courts or Member States,” PwC said.

The report questioned the “plausibility and reliability” of the data provided by Prognos because it could not apparently be reconciled with official data from the German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety (BMU), which has calculated the number of direct and indirect jobs related to the PV sector.

The Prognos study said a duty rate of 35% would result in the loss of 119,700 jobs in the first year of tariffs, and at 60% would claim 193,700 jobs.

But PwC said these figures exceed the total number of jobs in the industry in the BMU study.

Paulette Vander Schueren, spokesperson for AFASE told PV-Tech that the Prognos study used figures provided by the European Photovoltaic Industry Association (EPIA) that took into account rising demand for solar.

“The impact of the duties cannot be accurately calculated without this being taken into account,” Schueren said. “Moreover, the results of the Prognos study are based on conservative calculations.”

The PwC report also considered evidence from the US where a similar trade case was concluded last year and the effects the tariffs imposed by the US Department of Commerce on Chinese manufacturers had on the US PV industry.

The Coalition for Affordable Solar Energy in the US, which opposed duties, commissioned the Brattle Group to conduct a study that predicted “substantial price increases for crystalline photovoltaic cells and modules” and a corresponding decline in demand by residential, commercial and utility customers.

However, PwC concluded that developments since tariffs were imposed in the US have not shown this to be true.

The report acknowledged that the European and US markets are not identical, but drew parallels between the Brattle Group and the Prognos studies in terms of the “unreliable overestimation of negative employment effects which in the case of the US has already been rebutted by reality”.

Prognos argued that a comparison between the US and EU markets was “irrelevant and not a threshold to measure the effect that duties might have on the EU PV value chain”.

The US duties apply to cells of Chinese origin whether or not integrated into modules, whereas the EU tariffs would cover wafers, cells and modules.

As a result, Prognos said modules manufactured in China from non-Chinese cells are not subject to the US anti-dumping and/or countervailing duties.

“If imports into the US of modules manufactured in China incorporating Chinese cells have decreased while US installations have spiked, it is precisely because demand is being met by modules manufactured in China using non-Chinese cells in addition to modules manufactured outside China.”

In April, the Coalition for American Solar Manufacturing, which launched the trade case against Chinese manufacturers in the US, released a statement claiming some importers may either be improperly declaring merchandise as not subject to the AD/CVD orders, or may be understating the value of the imported merchandise declared as subject to the relevant orders.

Schueren said: “If the US duties are not fully efficient, no wonder that they do not have an effect on the PV value chain.”

Milan Nitzschke, president of EU ProSun, told attendees of the European Commission’s the first Global Solar Summit last week: “Only anti-dumping measures can prevent the creation of a Chinese monopoly, which would lead to higher prices, less innovation and even further job losses in Europe.

“China is burning up millions of euros in Europe and is destroying the best solar industry sector in the world due to price dumping.

Speaking at the same event, Guangbin Sun, general secretary of the solar division for the Chinese Chamber of Commerce, said: “If exports from China are impeded, the consequences will fall on the costs of European products. Nevertheless, we are willing to collaborate and maintain a dialogue in order to bring our production in line with market demand.”

Last week, PV-Tech reported that the European Commission is planning to impose between 37.2% and 67.9% tariffs on Chinese solar module manufacturers. If approved by member states, these figures will be published in the Official Journal next month.

26 January 2022
Join this free webinar for our analysis of the growth of N-Type technology including; new capacity expansions and production output. We'll also be looking at the global manufacturing footprint with forecasts on how much product will be made outside of China this year and which companies are driving technology change across the crystalline silicon value chain.
23 February 2022
Held annually since 2016, the Energy Storage Summit Europe is the place to be for senior stakeholders in the European storage industry. Designed to accelerate deployment of storage, we examine evolving chemistries, business models, project design, revenue stacks and use cases for storage. The 2022 edition will include exclusive content around longer duration solutions, energy strategies for wide-scale deployment of EVs and "EnTech", the event which sits at the intersection of digitisation, decentralisation and decarbonation of the power system. Come to meet TSOs, DSOs, Utilities, Developers, Investors and Lenders and leave with new contacts, partners and a wealth of information.
7 March 2022
Take your chance to join the most powerful platform in the MENA region. Middle East Energy (MEE), Intersolar, and ees, the leading energy exhibitions are joining hands to co-deliver an outstanding renewables and energy storage event at Middle East Energy 2021. Renewables and energy storage at MEE is the largest gathering of solar and renewable energy industry professionals in the Middle East & Africa, offering the most effective trade focused platform to international manufacturers and distributors looking to meet regional buyers.
8 March 2022
As Solar Finance & Investment enters its ninth year, we sit on the cusp of a new power market with solar at its heart. The 2022 edition of the event will build on our years of expertise and relationships to bring investors and lenders together with top developers. Connect with leaders in the field and use exclusive insights to drive investment and development decisions for the future. Meet new and existing project partners at the largest gathering of European solar investors and lenders.
23 March 2022
When it comes to storage, the US market exceeded a gigawatt of advanced energy storage installations (weighted towards lithium ion) at 1.46 GW, more than the previous six years in total! An exponential growth rate could see the market hit 7.5 GW p.a. by 2025. The summit will provide a wealth of content around this vital piece in the US power puzzle, with sessions dedicated to explore how companies are making money from batteries, the latest chemistries and their applications as they apply to different use-cases. We ask how investors can match ESG criteria to batteries and we will bring case studies of successful deployment and project execution onto the stage to examine how you can ensure your own projects are successful.
29 March 2022
Now in its 10th sell-out year, Large Scale Solar returns to Lisbon in 2022. We are excited to gather together face-to-face with the European solar industry as we provide unique and exclusive access to a powerful selection of the market's key stakeholders. Join this elite summit to find out how the market is maturing, which new markets are becoming more exciting, how technology is evolving and who's driving the market forward into the 2020s. Always senior, packed with developers, EPCs, utilities and investors this is the event for companies serious about European solar PV.

Read Next

January 19, 2022
Chinese inverter manufacturer Sungrow has launched its new "1+X" central modular inverter with an output of 1.1MW at the World Future Energy Summit in Abu Dhabi.
January 19, 2022
Innovative Solar Systems (ISS), a utility-scale solar developer with a 12GW pipeline, has put itself up for sale, as it seeks partners to support the company in its development of ever larger PV projects across the US.
PV Tech Premium
January 19, 2022
Latin America is fast becoming a lucrative solar market as countries ramp up deployment efforts. In this context, Colombia and Panama stand out as key markets to look out for, MPC Energy Solutions' CEO tells PV Tech Premium
January 19, 2022
US solar developer 8minute Solar Energy has closed US$400 million in financing from institutional investor EIG to bolster its US solar PV and energy storage pipeline.
January 19, 2022
Renewables developer R.Power has signed a power purchase agreement (PPA) with energy trader Axpo for nearly 300MWp of solar in Poland.
January 19, 2022
Energy major Shell has acquired 100% of PV project developer Solar-Konzept Italia (SKI), taking its solar development pipeline in Italy to around 2GW in the process.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
January 26, 2022
Free Webinar
Solar Media Events
February 23, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 8, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 23, 2022
Austin, Texas, USA
Solar Media Events
March 29, 2022
Lisbon, Portugal