Carbon named as challenger to JA Solar TOPCon patent

By Ben Willis and JP Casey
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Email
The European Patent Office headquarters.
Carbon initiated the challenge to the validity of JA Solar’s patent in the EPO. Image: Kārlis Dambrāns via Flickr.

The French start-up PV producer Carbon has emerged as a third actor in the ongoing patent dispute between rival Chinese manufacturers JA Solar and Astronergy.

JA Solar is suing Astronergy through the United Patent Court (UPC) over the alleged infringement of two of its patents, EP2787541B1 and EP4092759B1, both relating to aspects of its tunnel oxide passivated contact (TOPCon) technology.

This article requires Premium SubscriptionBasic (FREE) Subscription

Unlock unlimited access for 12 whole months of distinctive global analysis

Photovoltaics International is now included.

  • Regular insight and analysis of the industry’s biggest developments
  • In-depth interviews with the industry’s leading figures
  • Unlimited digital access to the PV Tech Power journal catalogue
  • Unlimited digital access to the Photovoltaics International journal catalogue
  • Access to more than 1,000 technical papers
  • Discounts on Solar Media’s portfolio of events, in-person and virtual

Or continue reading this article for free

Last week, PV Tech reported that the European Patent Office (EPO), a separate entity to the UPC where the main case will be heard, had “upheld as valid” one of the two patents at the centre of the dispute with Astronergy: EP2787541 B1. Clearing this hurdle is a positive development for JA Solar’s ongoing case with the UPC, although it will not determine the ultimate outcome of the UPC cases and can be appealed.

It has since emerged that it was Carbon that initiated the challenge to the validity of JA Solar’s patent in the EPO. Carbon has plans for a manufacturing facility in the south of France, in which it initially plans to produce TOPCon modules, and ensuring its products do not fall foul of other companies’ patents will be a priority for the company.

“In 2022, at the launch of the project, Carbon ran a thorough Freedom To Operate (FTO) on TOPCon,” a Carbon spokesperson told PV Tech this week. “At that time, Carbon identified a single patent on TOPCon, which was very broad, originally from LG, Korea and owned by Jinko. A few months ago, JA Solar bought the patent portfolio from Jinko.”

“As a reminder, TOPCon is a technology invented and developed in the European labs,” added the Carbon spokesperson. “We need to keep in mind that the TOPCon technology is very broad, shared and offers different possible technological pathways.”

No lawsuits have been filed against Carbon

The Carbon spokesperson added that: “there is no lawsuit from JA Solar against Carbon and the consortium of European partners Carbon is involved in,” following speculation that the ongoing legal challenges included a lawsuit filed against Carbon.

“The European consortium Carbon is involved in is now exploring the possibility of appeal, with even more European actors involved,” added the spokesperson.

“In general, Carbon will not lower its guard on these IP matters, because what is at stake is our strategic autonomy, technological independence and industrial sovereignty. As Europeans actors, we should not give up on defending the technologies that were created in Europe by Europeans. It is also a way to support the renaissance of the European PV industry.”

Carbon’s comments come amid growing interest in European PV manufacturing, alongside financial struggles at leading European manufacturer Meyer Burger, which has raised questions about the viability of large-scale European PV manufacturing.

‘A preliminary opinion, not a conclusion’

Meanwhile, Astronergy is making preparations for its main lawsuit with JA Solar. An Astronergy spokesperson told PV Tech this week that: “The Carbon opposition case focuses on the reasons and evidence previously raised by Carbon.”

“EPO’s information about the result of the oral proceedings is a preliminary opinion, not a conclusion. Moreover, at this stage, the outcome of this case does not directly affect the result of JA’s lawsuit against Astronergy.”

“At present, the case is still in its early stages. Based on previous cases, the litigation process for the entire case may last for one or two years, or even longer. Further disclosure on the relevant litigation strategies and core evidence is not appropriate at present since the JA patent case has not yet been heard in the UPC.

“However, both Carbon and Astronergy believe the patents in the JA patent case are not valid.”

26 November 2024
Málaga, Spain
Understanding PV module supply to the European market in 2025. PV ModuleTech Europe 2024 is a two-day conference that tackles these challenges directly, with an agenda that addresses all aspects of module supplier selection; product availability, technology offerings, traceability of supply-chain, factory auditing, module testing and reliability, and company bankability.
11 March 2025
Frankfurt, Germany
The conference will gather the key stakeholders from PV manufacturing, equipment/materials, policy-making and strategy, capital equipment investment and all interested downstream channels and third-party entities. The goal is simple: to map out PV manufacturing out to 2030 and beyond.
17 June 2025
Napa, USA
PV Tech has been running PV ModuleTech Conferences since 2017. PV ModuleTech USA, on 17-18 June 2025, will be our fourth PV ModulelTech conference dedicated to the U.S. utility scale solar sector. The event will gather the key stakeholders from solar developers, solar asset owners and investors, PV manufacturing, policy-making and and all interested downstream channels and third-party entities. The goal is simple: to map out the PV module supply channels to the U.S. out to 2026 and beyond.

Read Next

November 4, 2024
The cases are being pursued against JinkoSolar, Canadian Solar, JA Solar, and Trinasolar, some of the world's largest PV manufacturers.
October 30, 2024
JinkoSolar has published its financial results for the third quarter of the year, which include the shipments of over 23.8GW of modules.
Premium
October 24, 2024
Fierce competition and the emergence of technologies such as TOPCon have led to an uptick in the prevalence of patent infringement lawsuits between PV companies. Tom Kenning reports.
October 23, 2024
Filed in the US District Court for the District of Delaware, the lawsuit is in regard to two of Trina Solar's TOPCon patents.
October 22, 2024
LONGi and the School of Materials at Sun Yat-sen have developed HJT back contact solar cells with a power conversion efficiency of 27.09%.
October 17, 2024
Construction firm ARCO/Murray has been selected to lead the design and construction of Vietnamese solar manufacturer Boviet Solar’s 2GW TOPCon module assembly plant alongside the anticipated solar cell plant in North Carolina, US.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
November 12, 2024
San Diego, USA
Solar Media Events, Upcoming Webinars
November 13, 2024
4pm GMT / 8am PST
Solar Media Events
November 19, 2024
Philadelphia, USA
Solar Media Events
November 20, 2024
Zhuhai, China
Solar Media Events
November 21, 2024
London, UK