Proposed US solar trade tariff changes ‘illegal’

October 8, 2014
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Email

Proposals sent out for comment by the US Department of Commerce (DoC) that would extend the scope of the ongoing trade case could be illegal, according to a lawyer representing the Chinese government.

The DoC has suggested that products with Chinese or Taiwanese cells and modules assembled in China with cells from any other country be included in the scope of the ongoing investigation.

This article requires Premium SubscriptionBasic (FREE) Subscription

Try Premium for just $1

  • Full premium access for the first month at only $1
  • Converts to an annual rate after 30 days unless cancelled
  • Cancel anytime during the trial period

Premium Benefits

  • Expert industry analysis and interviews
  • Digital access to PV Tech Power journal
  • Exclusive event discounts

Or get the full Premium subscription right away

Or continue reading this article for free

This would include US-based cell maker Suniva. Suniva has already asked the DoC to exclude US cells from the scope.

Richard Weiner, lawyer with Sidley Austin representing Chinese manufacturers, said the change, if adopted, would fall foul of WTO and US rule.

“We are studying the proposal and it appears to expand the scope beyond the scope at initiation [of the investigation] which would be contrary to applicable law,” Weiner told PV Tech.

“It risks treating China less favourably than other countries in contravention to WTO most favoured nation provision in the WTO anti-dumping agreement,” he added.

The most favoured nation regulation means trading partners must be treated equally. Using different criteria for inclusion for China than for other countries would appear to breach this, Wiener said.

“The good news is that the DoC is ready to jettison SolarWorld’s proposed ‘two out of three’ rule, which was never capable of proper administration. But what stands in its place is another proposed rule that is equally incapable of administration,” added Weiner.

Malaysian and Korean cell manufacturers could also be affected if Chinese manufacturers can no longer use their cells to create tariff-free modules.

Tim Brightbill, chief trade counsel for SolarWorld and a partner at Wiley Rein, welcomed the proposals however.

“We appreciate the department’s scope proposal, which we view as a positive development in these cases. Commerce’s proposal appears to be comprehensive and would address all of China and Taiwan’s unfair trade practices,” Brightbill said in a statement to PV Tech.

“The proposed scope would also be much easier for Commerce to administer and for US Customs and Border Protection to enforce. SolarWorld will continue to review the proposal and will provide comments as appropriate,” added Brightbill.

Comments on the proposals are due on 14 October with rebuttal comments due on 20 October.

Read Next

October 23, 2025
The average price of a solar PPA signed in Europe in Q3 2025 fell below €35/MWh, reaching €34.25/MWh, according to LevelTen Energy.
October 23, 2025
Infrastructure investment firm Nuveen Infrastructure has secured US$171 million in financing for a 137MW solar PV plant in South Korea.
October 23, 2025
US solar manufacturer T1 Energy sold approximately 725MW of solar modules in Q3 2025, as it continues to expand US manufacturing capabilities.
Sponsored
October 23, 2025
Tongwei's rooftop-focused TNC 2.0 G12R-48 module will be among the products on show at All Energy Australia next week.
October 23, 2025
Solar PV technology has maintained its leading position as the most cost-competitive power generation source in 2025, according to analyst Wood Mackenzie.
October 23, 2025
Aviva Investors and Astatine have announced an €800 million (US$928 million) investment in renewable energy and decarbonisation solutions.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
November 25, 2025
Warsaw, Poland
Solar Media Events
December 2, 2025
Málaga, Spain
Solar Media Events
February 3, 2026
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 10, 2026
Frankfurt, Germany
Solar Media Events
March 24, 2026
Lisbon, Portugal