Solarcity files legal complaint with New Zealand’s EA over discriminatory ‘solar tax’

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Email
Solarcity's legal complaints contend that the higher lines charges for solar customers is an abuse of monopoly power and contrary to the Electricity Industry Participation Code. Source: Flickr - steakpinball

The solar energy industry is fighting back against taxes being imposed by lines companies [grid operators] on customers installing solar PV panels on their homes, by taking a case to the Electricity Authority.

The higher lines charge has prompted New Zealand power provider Solarcity to file a series of legal complaints with its Electiricty Authority (EA) today, asking it to stop electricity solutions group Unison Energy’s ‘solar tax’, on the grounds that it wrongfully disadvantages customers and is in clear violation of the Electricity Industry Participation Code on two counts.

Last month, Hawke’s Bay-based Unison became the first line company in New Zealand to increase line charges for residential customers who generate their own electricity. Customers who use a combination of solar energy and electricity in the grid in the catchment areas of Hawke’s Bay, Taupo and Rotorua are now subject to higher fees for new installations, while existing customers will stay on their current rate until March 2019.

But since the Unison charge was publicised, Solarcity has alleged that other lines companies have introduced – or are deliberating over introducing – additional charges by stealth. For example, WEL Networks has also added solar charges that tax customers for power they export for free.

Unison defended its actions by contending that solar electricity users who connected to its network had been subsidised by other power consumers, so a lift in charges was necessary.

Solarcity however argued in its complaint to the EA that Unison’s decision to unilaterally increase charges would add up to hundreds of dollars per year, and are contrary to ambitions and incentives signed under the Paris Climate Agreement, which was recently ratified in New York.

“While Unison doesn’t like the choices its customers are making, and doesn’t like losing revenue to solar, in New Zealand, we expect companies to respond to competition and innovation with better service, lower costs, and increased efficiency, not punish them with unfair charges,” said Andrew Booth, Solarcity CEO, in a statement. “What Unison – and indeed other companies – are doing is unacceptable, unlawful, and a clear abuse of monopoly power.

“New Zealand’s record on climate change, with the recent decision to keep Huntly open, is rapidly impacting our nation’s history of leadership, which has always seen us step up when the world needs us most.

“Solar has an important role in building a 100% renewable future for our world and climate scientists have told us that this is the decade to take decisive action to prevent catastrophic global warming.

“One roof at a time, kiwis across the nation are showing they want to work together to win the planetary race to be the first to be 100% renewable. The Electricity Authority and the government must take decisive action to prevent them being taxed and marginalised by monopoly businesses who put profit before people and the environment.”

Solarcity also contended that Unison’s charge was likely to result in fewer residents installing solar panels, leading to less take-up of renewable energy. However, a March 2016 report released by the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment, Jan Wright, concluded that solar panels contributed minimally to reducing New Zealand’s carbon footprint. In winter the CO2 emissions from generating electricity reach their peak, with solar panels being most effective in summer.

In addition, Unison business assurance general manager Nathan Strong said in widely reported statements that customers with solar would continue to pay lower annual charges under their new approach than a non-solar customer.

In any event, Solarcity’s legal complaints have started a crucial dialogue over monopoly powers exercised by state utilities. 

4 October 2022
Solar & Storage Finance USA, the only event that connects developers to capital and capital to solar and storage projects, will be back in November 2022.
27 October 2022
The advanced technology and innovative features of the new ES G2 3kW to 6kW single phase hybrid inverter enable increased savings, with smart loading for optimally timed energy consumption. Join this 40-minute webinar to learn how a true hybrid inverter operates to maximise PV based savings and how the ES G2 addresses the requirements of residential customers.

Read Next

September 30, 2022
US renewable energy major Brookfield Renewable has agreed to spend up to US$2 billion in order to acquire both Scout Clean Energy and Standard Solar.
September 28, 2022
The ENACT Installer App automates the complete journey of the customer, right from first contact to complete installation.
September 20, 2022
From module makers and BOS producers to utility-scale developers and community solar companies, the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) has taken centre stage at this year’s RE+ in Anaheim, California.
September 20, 2022
US thin-film module manufacturer Toledo Solar is planning to expand production in response to the passage of the Inflation Reduction Act.
PV Tech Premium
September 19, 2022
The proliferation of solar requires PV projects to adapt to their grid surroundings, which increasingly entails connecting alongside adjacent technologies, be it energy storage, other renewables or green hydrogen. Amid the growing threat of curtailment, Jules Scully looks at the rise of the ‘solar-plus’ market and the financial models underpinning it.
September 14, 2022
Private equity giant BlackRock Real Assets has acquired New Zealand solar and energy storage provider solarZero.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
October 4, 2022
New York, USA
On-Demand Webinars, Solar Media Events
October 11, 2022
Virtual event
Upcoming Webinars
October 18, 2022
10am (EDT) / 4pm (CEST)