The true costs of solar leasing

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on reddit
Reddit
Share on email
Email

The successful deployment of renewable energy, including solar, is critical for America’s future energy supply. Recently, a lease financing mechanism has been one of the most powerful drivers of solar power deployment in the US. Though solar leases have helped grow the industry, the authors contend that they come at an inflated and higher than intended cost to the US taxpayer compared to cash purchases. Further, if these inflated taxpayer costs become politicized, the industry may suffer another setback.

A press release issued by a major leasing company in October 2011 indicated leased systems have surpassed cash purchases in California, as supported by data from the California Solar Initiative (CSI). In 2008 leased residential PV systems represented ~6% of the number of installations in the market tracked by the CSI. As of April 2012 that number is now ~60% and growing. Like many other financial products that proliferate without being matched by a change in an underlying hard asset, the solar lease warrants further scrutiny.

Counter to normal business logic, profit in the solar leasing model is driven in part by higher costs (and not higher production), as far as permitted by regulation. The authors contend that solar lessors exaggerate costs to inflate tax benefits. The solar lessors profit by syndicating these tax benefits to large corporations or banks to decrease their tax liabilities. This is achieved by carefully manipulating lease structures to avoid triggering certain IRS rules and the application of certain Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. This blog will attempt to explain the accounting structures and finally an analysis of the ultimate cost to the taxpayer of this financial frenzy. 

As the full-length article, to appear in the next edition of Solar Business Focus, will show in more detail, the US taxpayer may over time pay for the entire system in lost tax revenue and dubious tax credits. We seek to explain the structures used and the resulting costs to the taxpayer as clearly as possible. We base our analysis largely on the financial structures described in a patent filed by a major California-based leasing company.

For bookkeeping purposes under Fair Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) rules, a solar lease must be structured as an “operating lease,” and must avoid characteristics that would trigger a “capital lease” designation. The FASB/GAAP treatment primarily applies to businesses seeking off-balance sheet financing, a controversial accounting method. In order to qualify as an operating lease and not a capital lease (also known as a financing lease, which would appear as a liability), the following requirements apply:

1. The lease payments under contract must not exceed 90% of the fair market value of the equipment;
2. The term must be less than 75% of the useful life of the PV system;
3. Ownership must not default to the lessee (typically the host of the PV system) at the end of the lease term and;
4. The buyout price must be about fair market value – no US$1 basement buyout price. As the referenced patent reads: “…customers are given fair market value buyout options, which are priced so that they would not fail one of the capital lease tests.”

The manipulation of these rules is a controversial tax tactic used in other capital intensive industries, such as airlines. Simply put, an operating lease appears in a company’s income statement as an operating expense. This lets the lessee/host take on the liability of the lease without the lease affecting its balance sheet, which would reduce its book value and leveragable assets.

Solar leasing companies use IRS and Treasury rules in order to make every installation as valuable a tax asset as possible. A key method for achieving this goal is to structure leases as a true lease rather than a tax-oriented lease. As a true lease, SolarLease Co. and SunFund, our hypothetical lease originators and finance backers, are owners of the financial attributes of the system, and are able to collect depreciation benefits a residential system purchased with cash is ineligible to collect. The financial attributes of a system are created through three key levers:

1. For Ms. Cali, a hypothetical homeowner, – paying for the lease via a tax deductible home equity line of credit. The tax deduction is an effective subsidization.
2. For SolarLease Co. and SunFund, inflating the total installed cost of the project generates
a. The largest investment tax credit possible
b.  A higher depreciable tax basis

The most recent eligible cost basis was issued in the Treasury’s Fair Market Value Assessment, set as of the first quarter of 2011, according to the schedule in Table 1.

Most solar professionals would agree that +/- US$7.00/w is out of line with current market realities.

To a homeowner paying for a system in cash, the installed cost dictates the long-term net present values and rates of return, which are the fundamental metrics used to determine whether to purchase a PV system. On the other hand, if a homeowner receives a flat monthly lease rate, she probably doesn’t care what the cost benchmarks and rules are for tax treatment. This is part of the appeal.

One of the largest leasing company’s average reported cost under the California Solar Initiative for residential projects installed in 2011 was US$7.91/Wp. Another large leasing provider in California reported an average cost of US$8.28/Wp. This compares to the first company’s average cash, non-third-party owned system, cost of US$6.40/Wp. Meanwhile, many firms install residential projects on a cash basis for a cost of US$4-5/Wp. Property owners who have purchased and installed their own PV systems reported an average installed cost of US$4.56/Wp in 2011. 

To get a handle on what these three levers cost the US taxpayer; let’s take the 2kW, US$15k system described in the referenced patent. Assume, as documented in the patent, that the lease payments of US$100/month are paid for by an interest-only home equity loan. Assuming a 5% discount rate, the US$33/month over 20 years results in a present value of avoided taxes due of US$5,021.

For SolarLease Co. and SunFund, the total value of the depreciation benefit, assuming a 5% discount rate and 35% corporate tax rate, is about US$2,718.Provided the 30% investment tax credit is taken and used in the year one (it must be fully used within five years). With a 5% discount rate, the present value of the credit is US$2,857. The full-length article will describe these costs in greater detail.

Summing up the above, (which is based on the patent, and very basic economic logic) the total present value cost to American taxpayer is US$10,600, or greater than the total estimated cost of the system. Excluding the tax breaks from Ms. Cali’s HELOC (which are difficult to predict or pinpoint), the lost taxes to the Treasury are US$5,575 – greater than half the total (perhaps inflated) cost of the system. 82% of this is realized in year one. Thus the taxpayer picks up 46% of the total present value of the system cost in the first year alone, excluding any HELOC tax breaks, or any costs picked up by tax or ratepayers such as SRECs, rebates, FITs, and other tax abatements.

Though solar leasing has aided the growth of the US solar industry, the authors believe this financial product could negatively affect the industry in the long-term. The Solyndra, Abound, Evergreen Solar and Energy Conversion Devices bankruptcies dramatically decreased the appetite for risky government subsidization of green energy manufacturing. If the inflated taxpayer cost of the solar leasing product – and the companies that ultimate benefit from its sharp growth – become widely understood, the result may be another setback in the public acceptance of government assisted green energy development.

This is an abridged version of a full article that will be published in the upcoming edition of the Solar Business Focus publication. You can download the full article prior to the magazine's publication by clicking here.
 

1 December 2021
Join this virtual conference on 1-2 December 2021 for expert presentations covering PV Module Technology, Supply & Site Optimisation for Utility-Scale. Delegates can access streamed presentations, session recordings and chat/messaging tools to connect with fellow delegates and speakers. Speakers include leading developers, manufacturers, testing and research institutes, including: NREL, Silicon Ranch, Sonnedix, Heliene, Powertis, LONGi Solar, JinkoSolar, PVEL, Risen Energy, Seraphim, STS, Trina Solar, Eternalsun Spire, QEERI, Fraunhofer, Estuary Capital Partners and VDE
2 December 2021
Intersolar is the world’s leading exhibition & conference series for the solar industry. As part of this event series, Intersolar India in Mumbai is India’s most pioneering exhibition and conference for India’s solar industry. It takes place annually and has a focus on the areas of photovoltaics, PV production and solar thermal technologies. Since 2019, Intersolar India is held under the umbrella of The smarter E India – India’s innovation hub for the new energy world.
9 December 2021
The Smart Energy Council is hosting Australia’s second Virtual Smart Energy Conference and Exhibition on Thursday, 9 December 2021. This event will show that the industry powers on despite COVID-19 and we are standing together undeterred in spirit. Bringing our global community together using the latest technology.
13 January 2022
Intersolar North America and Energy Storage North America “Come Together” for the first time in Long Beach, CA—connecting installers, developers, utilities, technology providers, policy makers, and key stakeholders from around the world to advance the clean energy future. With best-in-class conference programming, integrated exhibits and pavilions, and the live Solar Games installer competition, #isnaesna21 will showcase the industry trends, innovative solutions, and emerging talent transforming the solar, energy storage, and e-mobility markets. Register today to redeem our exclusive offer for PV Tech readers—free expo hall or 20% off full conference pass.
1 February 2022
As Solar Finance & Investment enters its ninth year, we sit on the cusp of a new power market with solar at its heart. The 2022 edition of the event will build on our years of expertise and relationships to bring investors and lenders together with top developers. Connect with leaders in the field and use exclusive insights to drive investment and development decisions for the future. Meet new and existing project partners at the largest gathering of European solar investors and lenders.
23 February 2022
Held annually since 2016, the Energy Storage Summit Europe is the place to be for senior stakeholders in the European storage industry. Designed to accelerate deployment of storage, we examine evolving chemistries, business models, project design, revenue stacks and use cases for storage. The 2022 edition will include exclusive content around longer duration solutions, energy strategies for wide-scale deployment of EVs and "EnTech", the event which sits at the intersection of digitisation, decentralisation and decarbonation of the power system. Come to meet TSOs, DSOs, Utilities, Developers, Investors and Lenders and leave with new contacts, partners and a wealth of information.

Read Next

November 26, 2021
Renewables developer and asset owner Grasshopper Energy has signed an agreement that could support the development of up to 1GW of solar in Romania by 2030.
November 26, 2021
Portugal has launched its latest solar auction that is set to allocate 262MW of floating PV to be installed at seven dams across the country.
November 26, 2021
The European Commission (EC) has approved a €2.27 billion (US$2.56 billion) Greek scheme to support 4.2GW of installed renewables capacity after assessing it in the context of EU state aid rules
PV Tech Premium
November 26, 2021
Average market prices for 182mm solar wafers fell by nearly 7% this week, falling to levels not seen in almost two months, however other material and component costs have remained high.
PV Tech Premium
November 26, 2021
Faced with the threat of curtailment as more renewables enter the grid, utility-scale solar developers are heightening their focus on hybrid PV-storage projects to take advantage of demand for flexibility services and falling battery costs.
November 25, 2021
Assurance and risk management provider DNV is acquiring cyber security firm Applied Risk as it looks to build a security practice focused on defending industrial assets against emergent cyber threats.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
December 1, 2021
Solar Media Events
February 1, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
February 23, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 23, 2022
Austin, Texas, USA
Solar Media Events
March 29, 2022
Lisbon, Portugal