‘A troubling reality’: Study claims swathes of US solar projects underperforming

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email
Image: SEIA/Twitter.

A new study suggests the US solar industry has “turned a blind eye” to the realities of asset performance, with facilities found to be underperforming compared to their production forecasts.

In collaboration with ten of 15 largest US solar asset owners, risk management company kWh Analytics analysed more than 30% of the industry’s utility-scale and commercial and industrial solar projects and found a quarter missed their production targets by over 10%, even after adjusting for weather.

While the sector uses the same software tools and engineering firms to generate production estimates, a lack of accepted standards means that forecasts can vary depending on who is running the model, the report says.

According to kWh Analytics, when solar was still an untested asset class in the early 2000s, initial estimates were conservative and projects typically outperformed expectations. However, with the pace of market development, new technologies, more complicated site designs and a more competitive landscape, production estimation became more complex, leading to forecasting becoming overly optimistic.

“Fundamentally, it is our hope that this report serves as a platform to discuss the data-driven approaches to inform deployment of capital,” kWh Analytics said in a statement accompanying the study.

The firm quantified the magnitude of the industry’s inaccuracy when relying on P50 estimates, a statistical measure that indicates the base case, predicted energy yield.

The analysis of more than 30% of the industry’s non-residential projects in the US compared actual production against original P50 estimates for operating years between 2016 and 2019 and found that projects on average underperformed by 6.3%. The results do not incorporate system losses due to utility curtailment.

kWh says the performance results against P50 estimates highlight “a troubling reality”: that the industry is “relying on inaccurate and unreliable production estimates”.

Efforts are said to be underway to correct the issue, with solar asset owners collaborating to quantify potential biases and using data to drive accuracy and transparency in future financings.

“While developers may be concerned about the near-term impact on solar asset valuations resulting from adjusted P50 estimates, we believe that this course correction will enable our industry to continue the structural trend of lower-cost capital entering into the industry,” kWh Analytics said in the report. “This ultimately has a positive impact on solar asset valuations.”

Read Next

October 15, 2021
European renewables investment management firm Greencoat Capital has confirmed its entry to the US renewables market and is plotting to invest up to US$5 billion over the next five years.
PV Tech Premium
September 13, 2021
Following the release of the US Department’s Solar Futures Study, Liam Stoker assesses the downstream and upstream trends that must be realised for US solar to fulfil its potential.
PV Tech Premium
September 3, 2021
PV Tech spoke to experts in the artificial intelligence-solar space to explore how it was being used in the industry and the potential benefits it could bring to the sector
August 25, 2021
The US renewables sector has welcomed the House of Representatives’ approval of a budget resolution that provides the framework for a US$3.5 trillion spending package.
August 24, 2021
Energy advisory DNV has acquired the consulting arm of Chile-based energy price forecaster Antuko, taking aim at the Latin America and Iberia power markets.
August 19, 2021
It may be the height of summer but there’s no respite for the Solar Media Podcast, the new episode of which is packed full of insight as the US begins its clampdown on solar imports.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
November 10, 2021
8am (PST) | 5pm (CET)
Solar Media Events
December 1, 2021