Report challenges short-term role of storage in Germany’s energy transition

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

Energy storage may not be cost effective in Germany in helping the transition to a higher grid penetration of renewable energy until that penetration level reaches as high as 90%, according to a leading think tank.

Agora Energiewende, a Germany-based think tank, published the report, ‘Electricity Storage in the German Energy Transition’, last week. The report models a handful of scenarios for the development of the ’Energiewende’ (’energy transition’), mapped against the government’s targets for renewable energy.

The report, which has attracted some controversial coverage from other media, in essence states that in the next 10 to 20 years, the use of energy storage is not likely to be a more effective integrator of renewable energy technology than a mixture of other options aimed at giving energy systems more added flexibility.

“There are cheaper ways of adding flexibility than storage, for example you can just turn off coal, or gas fired power plants, you can use electricity for power-to-heat, you can exchange with neighbouring countries,” said Daniel Fuerstenwerth, project manager at Agora Energiewende.

“There are other opportunities that are cheaper than storage, from the overall system perspective.”

By 2023, the country will aim to have brought the share of renewables-generated energy to 42%, by 2023 to 60% by 2033. The final scenario modelled takes an unspecified future time where Germany will finally reach 90% renewable energy penetration. According to Agora Energiewende, which contracted four research institutes to carry out the study, it will only be when renewable energy comes toward the 90% mark in the total energy mix that energy storage will be among the most economic facilitators for its integration.

“The discussion about storage in German has become more intense, because quite intuitively you’d say, ‘we’ve put a PV plant there or wind power and the energy produced is not stable, it’s fluctuating, so we’ll put storage there.’ That sounds, or ‘feels’ right for most people I would say, but it hasn’t been analysed in much detail yet,” said Fuerstenwerth.

“We asked four leading institutions to conduct research on how much storage the German energy transition needs, so assuming that all the scenarios currently being discussed, assuming that all of this comes true, how much storage do we need and when? The results were a bit surprising for many. By 2023 and 2033, adding storage to the system doesn’t really reduce total costs, while in the very long run, consultants found if you have 90% renewables, adding storage can add value and reduce total system costs.”

In the medium term, although not the long term, the use of storage could actually lead to an increase in the use of lignite at German power plants, Fuerstenwerth said.

“This study we did not look into the wider environmental index too much but we did have a bit of a look at CO2 emissions and we saw amongst other things that when you add a lot of storage to the German system – and maybe this is specific to the German situation – but in the medium term it increases the utilisation of lignite plants.

“If you don’t have additional storage, you really have to turn off the fossil fuel power plants, and you turn them off in order of cost logic. First you turn off the gas, then hard coal, then lignite power plants last, because they’re the cheapest. When you add storage to the system, besides integrating more renewables it also integrates more lignite because it avoids turning off lignite power plants.”

Fuerstenwerth emphasised however that there are a number of business cases for storage and that some uses for storage such as ancillary market participation, could be more economical than others, even in the short term.

“We looked at different applications for storage – power markets, balancing services, delaying grid expansion on the distribution grid level. We did find that adding a lot of storage can add a lot of costs. At the same time, and this was a very important result for us – there are already niche markets where for example battery technologies can add value or compete. For instance, primary reserve – the millisecond response or demand response – where in the case of the failure of a large power plant, there needs to be 600MW of primary reserve in the German market. So far this can only be provided by fossil fuel power plants and what we saw in the study was that batteries can add value there and are really well technically suited for that”.

Fuerstenwerth explained however that with radically different drivers to its adoption, storage made sense at the residential level where the drivers for its use were simpler, based around building greater individual electricity resilience and self-sufficiency.

“For the individual consumer, who has for example rooftop PV, as your feed-in tariff (FiT) is ending after 20 years but the PV plant is still producing electricity, then you have to compare your own cost for using the PV power with what you have to buy from the grid, so from an individual perspective it could make sense.”

Fuerstenwerth said that where residential storage was concerned, Agora Energiewende’s key condition was to make sure it didn’t “lead to a redistribution of costs”, as had been the case in Germany and other countries where the deployment of solar and other renewables at scale is financed by electricity surcharges on consumer electric bills.. Agora believes however that residential, customer-sited storage could have a “relieving effect on the distribution network when used in a grid-supporting manner”.

According to Agora Energiewende, there could also be significant drivers to the increase of energy storage deployment besides the energy market perspective – for instance, increasing electric vehicle (EV) sales.

Fuerstenwerth was keen to point out that many of these conclusions could be particular to Germany and the Germany energy industry and not necessarily mutable to other regions. For example, US utility company ConEdison is using a series of energy storage projects to stave off the need for over a billion dollars in infrastructure investment for substations and other power electronics.

Agora's former head, Rainer Baake, a Green Party politician, was appointed as economics and energy minister Sigmar Gabriel's deputy in the German coalition government at the beginning of this year.

This article has been amended to clarify a point on the redistribution of costs resulting from the increased deployment of renewables.

11 May 2021
Join this Talesun Solar webinar focused on providing an insight into the company’s next-generation series of large-area, high-efficiency PERC (Passivated Emitter Rear Cell) modules. These are available in both monofacial (‘BiStar’) and bifacial (‘BiPro’) formats, using 182mm half-cut cells in 144 and 156 cell configurations and provide up to 590Wp performance with efficiencies of up to 21.2%.
11 May 2021
Green Hydrogen: always the future never the now? Join us on 11-12 & 18-19 May for a fresh look at what’s fast becoming a reality. Governments across the world have put hydrogen at the centre of their decarbonisation plans with billions of dollars allocated to stimulating the market and whilst individual strategies will differ, the theme is the same: green hydrogen is the fuel of the future. Its role goes beyond energy use and there is already an active off-take market. From the perspective of renewable generators, hydrogen can play a pivotal role in enabling unsubsidised projects to work in a low power price environment and provide another business model in areas where the grid is congested. Hydrogen could also be the driver of a new wave of renewable installations as countries’ hydrogen plans hinge on new capacity being available.
26 May 2021
Tara Doyle and Tristan Erion-Lorico of PV Evolution Labs (PVEL), will share this year’s top-performing modules and discuss key findings from PVEL’s PQP testing. Join us to explore which find out which new Top Performer category can affect project value by more than $100,000 – and which test resulted in >20% degradation.
15 June 2021
Looking at the drivers and dynamics of utility scale solar in the UK over the next five years. This event will consider the immediate challenges as we enter the build phase in the UK market where we could see as much as 3GW deployed in 2021 alone! What developments will continue the growth of 100MW+ sites and what impact will government policy have on the rate of deployment in the UK? Join leading developers and manufacturers shaping the direction of one of Europe’s most active markets and hear from speakers with a history of influencing innovation and change.
6 July 2021
Explore in depth the opportunities of the different countries via case studies, business and financial models that will foster growth in the region with particular focus on Thailand, Philippines, Indonesia, Taiwan, Korea, Cambodia, Singapore, Malaysia & Vietnam.
13 July 2021
Energy Next is a new industry exhibition focusing on the latest renewable energy and energy efficiency technology, which will be held for the first time in 2021 in Sydney, Australia alongside the Clean Energy Council’s Australian Clean Energy Summit, the peak gathering of leaders driving Australia's energy transformation. Organised by the same people behind Australia’s largest clean energy event, All-Energy Australia, Energy Next will give visitors two days of access to key suppliers in the industry, free-to-attend professional development and industry workshops, and networking opportunities to better understand clean energy issues and solutions and learn about the latest developments in this transformational, dynamic sector.

Read Next

May 6, 2021
There needs to be a fourfold increase in the number of workers employed in the US solar industry for the country to achieve President Biden’s ambition of creating a carbon pollution-free power sector by 2035, a new report suggests.
May 5, 2021
Europe’s solar industry has lauded the inclusion of a commitment to "re-ignite" Europe's solar manufacturing sector within the European Commission’s refreshed industrial strategy.
May 5, 2021
A round-up of news from the US solar sector, including updates from the Department of Energy, private equity firm American Securities, and Indiana developer Hoosier.
May 5, 2021
New solar and wind assets in the US are now cheaper to operate than nearly 80% of existing coal-fired generators in the country and could replace the asset class while delivering numerous benefits to consumers, a report has found.
May 5, 2021
Governments worldwide must ensure that there are sufficient raw materials available to solar and energy storage developers to safeguard the energy transition.
May 5, 2021
The Australian Renewable Energy Agency (ARENA) has selected three commercial-scale green hydrogen projects that will share in AU$103 million (US$79.7 million) of funding to support their development.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
May 11, 2021
Upcoming Webinars
May 26, 2021
Session 1 - 7:00 AM (BST) | Session 2 - 5:00 PM (BST)
Solar Media Events
June 15, 2021
Solar Media Events
July 6, 2021