Discover our upstream and downstream technical journals
Senator Brandt Hersham, the Republican senator who authored the measure. Source: TheStatehousefile

Senator Brandt Hersham, the Republican senator who authored the measure. Source: TheStatehousefile

A bill that would end retail net metering in Indiana by significantly reducing the incentive available to invest in solar passed the Senate Utilities Committee in an 8-2 vote yesterday.

SB 309 would create three tiers of solar users: consumers who had installed panels up until the end of June would be grandfathered in at existing retail rates for the next 30 years, but those who install panels after June but before 2022 would be eligible for the retail rate until 2032. Anyone who installs panels after 2022 would receive a much lower rate of compensation, which critics feel would be the effective end of net metering in the state.

Bill amended after backlash

The bill was amended Thursday after it received significant backlash during a hearing last week. Originally, the bill would have required solar consumers to sell all the energy produced to the state utility at a lower wholesale rate of around US$0.03/kWh, and then purchase it back from the utility at the higher retail rate of around US$0.11/kWh.

Whilst the reworking of the bill means that there is less at stake for solar in Indiana, the current reading of the legislation still threatens to stifle residential solar.

Senator Jim Tomes voted in favour of the bill once the amendment was introduced.

"I was very clear that I was not going to vote for the bill in the way that it was," he said. “That was the same position I had when I walked into the committee room at 9 o'clock this morning. At 9:05, I saw for the first time the amendment that senator Delph [who sponsored the amendment] had introduced which changed the entire bill dramatically.”

The measure was peddled by Republican state senator Brandt Hershman who sided with utilities in the argument that the current net metering set up requires them to compensate solar users for power at retail rates. Hershman said the bill is a measured approach toward balancing the interests of utilities, while still supporting alternative energy sources "which I don't think is a very radical change" from current policy.

“Right now, you get a subsidy of over 300%,” Hershman said during the hearing. “That’s unsustainable because all the other rate payers end up footing the bill for that.”

Still deterring of renewables

Despite the amendment, which renders the bill far more palatable than it was before, solar supporters still feel that the situation ultimately boils down to a choice between consumer and utility interests.

For now, the bill awaits approval in the Statehouse. 

Tags: us, usa, indiana, bill, legislation, net metering, rate design, grandfathering, utilities

Upcoming Webinars

Revealing the most bankable and reliable PV module suppliers for utility-scale deployment in the US

Jan 20, 2021 GMT

Virtually all PV modules for large-scale utility-based solar sites are imported to the US, especially from Chinese companies using manufacturing sites across Southeast Asia. This puts extreme pressure on US site developers, EPCs and investors, in understanding fully the differences between the companies offering imported PV modules How credible are the companies supplying the products? What is the financial health of the parent entity? Where is the module produced, and is this undertaken in-house or through third-party OEMs? What is the supply-chain for the module sub-components including wafers and cells? And then, how will the modules perform in the field, and is it possible to gauge reliability levels benchmarked against competitors? This webinar will provide insights from two of the leading experts in PV module manufacturing, supply, performance and reliability: Jenya Meydbray of PV Evolution Labs and Finlay Colville from PV-Tech. The 1-hour session will include presentations from Jenya and Finlay, and then a brand-new supplier scorecard matrix that combines the key outputs from PVEL's Module Reliability Scorecard and PV-Tech's PV ModuleTech Bankability Ratings, with specific focus on module supply and use in the US market.

Register now

Comments