SolarWorld and Hemlock continue last ditch talks as ‘crucial’ court date cancelled

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

The hearing in a US court to decide whether SolarWorld is liable for damages in its case with Hemlock Semiconductor has been cancelled.

Hemlock is seeking US$770 million for what it claims are unfulfilled polysilicon contracts and filed for a summary judgement earlier in the year. A hearing was scheduled for June 23 but this has now been cancelled with no alternative date rescheduled. Staff at the court were unable to provide further details. On Monday Deutsche Solar, the subsidiary of SolarWorld named in the case, requested the court to re-open oral arguments, a move rejected by Hemlock, and then by the court itself.

SolarWorld has confirmed to PV Tech that talks with Hemlock are ongoing and the absence of a new date for the hearing could fuel speculation that a settlement has been reached or is sufficiently close that the hearing would have been counter-productive.

This week’s scheduled hearing created a flashpoint at SolarWorld’s AGM two weeks ago as investor and corporate governance figure Christian Strenger delivered a speech accusing the company’s management of underplaying the threat posed by a decision against it on June 23.

Strenger claimed that the company should have accounted for potential claims in the case in its accounts.

“The assertion that avoiding accruals even in the case of a negative decision [by the US] courts is justifiable – due to exigency there would be no enforcement of the decision in Germany – is hardly plausible. SolarWorld has, in the meantime, a high-level of commitments in the US market.”

SolarWorld has countered that a ruling in the US would not necessarily be applicable claiming that the contracts breach European anti-trust laws.

The court has yet to set a new date. Source: Flickr/steakpinball

“According to our risk assessment regarding Hemlock, the probability that an actual outflow of resources will take place is considered as low, since it is unlikely that Hemlock will be able to enforce a possible US ruling in Germany because the underlying contracts do not comply with European antitrust legislation,” Milan Nitzschke, vice president at SolarWorld told PV Tech.

“European law would have to be taken into a consideration by a German court,” he said, adding that international accounting rules state that there must be a “present obligation” with a probable “outflow of resources” and that “the amount of the obligation can be reliably estimated”.

A partial decision in the US case in November ruled against one form of an anti-trust defence.

Strenger also questioned why the company had failed to turn around its share price when fellow German manufacturer, the inverter firm SMA, had managed to arrest its slide with deep cuts and restructuring.

“The comparison with the last three years shows the near total loss of value in SolarWorld shares in opposition with the 80% gain in SMA [shares]. In 2015 SMA shares increased in value by 250%, while SolarWorld fell 50%,” Strenger told the AGM, also questioning why SolarWorld CEO Frank Asbeck was receiving a salary with performance of the shares so poor. Asbeck had previously pledged not to receive a remuneration until the company was profitable.

Nitzschke pointed out that the company was back in black in 2014 and Asbeck had fulfilled his voluntary pledge.

Hemlock Semiconductor was not immediately available for comment. 

26 January 2022
Join this free webinar for our analysis of the growth of N-Type technology including; new capacity expansions and production output. We'll also be looking at the global manufacturing footprint with forecasts on how much product will be made outside of China this year and which companies are driving technology change across the crystalline silicon value chain.

Read Next

January 10, 2022
Upstream solar major Tongwei has forecasted for profits to more-than-double in its 2021 financial year on the back of increased material and cell prices experienced last year.
PV Tech Premium
January 10, 2022
After a 2021 which saw price volatility dominate the solar industry’s new, the sector started anew last week. How has the downstream started the year with regards manufacturing and pricing?
January 7, 2022
The solar PV industry produced more than 190GW of modules during 2021, as the industry went through its first major production-led supply cycle, Finlay Colville reveals in exclusive analysis for PV Tech.
January 6, 2022
PV Tech speaks to Philipp Matter, president for Europe at GCL System Integration, to discuss last year's supply chain crises, targeting growth in Europe and the prospects for competing new solar technologies.
January 4, 2022
Daqo New Energy has provided a RMB10 billion (US$1.6 billion) capital injection to a subsidiary which is to advance on future polysilicon production projects in Inner Mongolia.
January 4, 2022
Solar manufacturer Risen Energy has revealed the details of a RMB44.6 billion (US$7 billion) manufacturing capacity expansion plan that will span n-type polysilicon ingots, modules and renewables projects.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
January 26, 2022
Free Webinar
Solar Media Events
February 23, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 8, 2022
London, UK
Solar Media Events
March 23, 2022
Austin, Texas, USA
Solar Media Events
March 29, 2022
Lisbon, Portugal