Spain Supreme Court ruling ‘oxygen’ for future solar cases

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email
The win for solar announced on 29 April has been welcomed by law firms and solar stakeholders. Credit: Evolutiza

The Spanish Supreme Court has ruled that solar PV companies and investors should be compensated by the Spanish administration over historic amendments to the feed-in-tariff (FiT) policy for new installations.

The win for solar announced on 29 April has been welcomed by law firms and solar stakeholders, who claim it may set a precedent for future cases, in a nation where the majority of legal cases of late have seen solar losing out. Spanish law firm Evolutiza Lawyers and Tax Advisors was responsible for filing the appeals in defence of the PV investors.

Daniel Pérez, attorney at Holtrop S.L.P, a law firm that has been heavily involved in other legal cases surrounding the Royal Decrees on solar, told PV Tech: “It is very good at least to have a partial win. But it is quite limited because it affects only one specific case, although it might be a precedent for future complaints.”

This is because the latest ruling only covers the moratorium on giving FiTs to new solar installations, which was a norm introduced by the Conservative Popular party after it came into power. Meanwhile, the ruling does not account for the retroactive cuts to the FiTs that were brought in for exiting installations.

Pérez said this means the compensation only covers investments made in presenting and promoting projects in planning, which is limited. Moreover most of the solar producers affected did not appeal because they saw that the first legal decisions surrounding the retroactive cuts to the FiT for existing installations had been lost.

Following the publication of Royal Decree Law 1/2012, which brought in the FiT changes, Evolutiza submitted claims for expenses and costs incurred by developers and PV investors, whose projects did not materialize. However the Cabinet dismissed the claims on 25 April 2014.

An appeal in the Supreme Court followed. Now the Spanish state has been forced to compensate investors and PV promoters after the Royal Decree-law 1/2012 was found to be “surprising, breaking the principle of legitimate expectations” set by the Royal Decree of 2008, which first introduced the FiT subsidy scheme.

Retribution cases

There are two main sets of cases regarding the retroactive cuts or “retribution” on the subsidies. The courts rejected the claims around the first cutbacks in 2010, ruling that there had been no impact. The second set of cases in relation to the cutbacks of 2013/14 are still pending.

Perez added: “This decision that appeared last week is a bit of oxygen for future decisions.”

Read Next

April 9, 2021
Spanish independent power producer Opdenergy is preparing to launch an initial public offering to help fund the development of 3.7GW of renewables projects across Europe and the Americas.
April 8, 2021
Iberdrola has formed a strategic alliance with insurance company Mapfre that will initially invest in 230MW of clean energy projects in Spain, including 130MW of solar PV.
March 29, 2021
Clean energy investment platform Renewable Power Capital (RPC) has announced the creation of a new joint venture that will develop and acquire 3.4GW of solar PV in Spain.
March 18, 2021
Residents living near two towns on the east coast of Spain will soon be able to sign up to receive power from the country’s first community agrophotovoltaic projects, which are being built to help reduce local electricity bills while exploring the impact solar shading has on the cultivation of tropical fruit.
March 16, 2021
A round-up of the latest solar project news from around the world, including updates from R.Power, Grenergy Renovables and Duke Energy Florida.
March 15, 2021
Spain’s government and the EU will provide funding to support the development of 65 new solar projects in the Canary Islands by the end of next year.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
April 13, 2021
Solar Media Events
April 20, 2021
Upcoming Webinars
April 28, 2021
4:00 - 4:30 PM CET