US government initiates investigation into Suniva’s trade complaint

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email

The US International Trade Commission (ITC) has elected to launch an investigation into Suniva’s trade complaint under Section 201 of the 1974 Trade Act. The body will decide whether to raise import prices on modules as per the bankrupt module manufacturer’s request.

The investigation will determine whether the glut of Asian imported crystalline silicon PV cells are causing a “substantial” cause or threat of “serious injury” to domestic manufacturing. After going bankrupt in April, Suniva placed the blame on the mass influx of cheap solar panels from Asia undercutting domestic production. The trade measures would apply to imports from all countries.

In response, Suniva put forward a petition to raise the Minimum Import Price (MIP) to 78 cents/w and requested a four-year tariff schedule on crystalline silicon imports. The petition raised concern among many manufacturing industry stakeholders, considering it could double the price of imported solar modules and relegate the economics of potential projects.

The ITC officially ruled to consider the case on Tuesday evening, and will come to an injury conclusion by 22 September 2017, after determining the investigation is “extraordinarily complicated”. After reaching its decision, the Commission will submit its remedy to the president within 180 days after the official petition submission date (17 May 2017) or by 13 November 2017.

It is up to president Trump to make the final decision on whether to provide a remedy to domestic manufacturers. The Commission may recommend to the president to increase a duty, impose a quota or a two-level tariff, or any combination of such actions. It could also recommend that the president initiate international negotiations with competitor module markets. China's ministry of commerce has already made known its feeling that Suniva’s request is an “abuse of trade remedies”. Overall, the decision lies with the president on which remedy to pursue, and may take action for an initial period of up to four years, according to the ITC.

Analysis: The Solyndra path…

Although Suniva's creditor SQN would seem to be offering non-US PV manufacturers a way out of going through the USITC investigation by buying the manufacturing assets of the bankrupt firm, options seem open to also follow the path successfully made by Solyndra’s lawyers in suing key PV manufacturers at the time such as Yingli Green Energy and Trina Solar.

After the bankruptcy of CIGS thin-film producer Solyndra and its assets sold-off in auctions, lawyers for the company filed anti-trust and unfair trade practice lawsuits against China-based manufacturers in 2012, for US$1.5 billion.

Ultimately, the suits lead to out of court settlements, which included Yingli Green paying US$7.5 million to Solyndra with a clause of a further US$10 million payment, should Yingli Green sell more than 800MW in the US and Canada in a single year between 2016 and 2018.

A heavier price was extracted from Trina Solar, which paid Solyndra US$45 million to settle the same claims.

– Mark Osborne –


“We are pleased that the Commission has taken this next step and initiated the investigation of this case. The company looks forward to working with the Commission as our petition moves forward,” said Matt Card, Suniva’s executive vice president of commercial operations.

The Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA), the body leading the opposition on Suniva’s case, expressed strong disappointment. The Association’s president and CEO Abigail Ross Hopper stated the threat to the American workforce, with the potential to “jeopardize billions of dollars in investment”.

“Setting high price floors and exorbitant tariffs is a blunt instrument that would cripple one of the brightest spots in America’s economy.

“While we respect the ITC's decision to evaluate this claim on its merits, SEIA will remain at the forefront of the opposition to Suniva's requested remedies. We encourage all members of the solar industry to assist the ITC if asked for information and to work with us to ensure your voice is heard. Our goal throughout this proceeding will remain focused on developing more equitable and sustainable ways to boost American solar manufacturing that benefit many companies instead of just a few and allows the entire solar industry to continue to grow in this country,” she said.

The danger lies in the fact that if the ITC complies with Suniva’s price recommendations for imported cells, module pricing in turn would increase, stalling industry progress. According to GTM Research, 13% of solar modules installed in the US last year were manufactured in the US; meaning 87% of the market will be subject to whatever remedies are imposed. 

Additional reporting by Mark Osborne

This article has been amended to clarify that it was SQN that sent the letter to the USITC.

19 July 2022
Free webinar - Hear an updated and live talk that was first delivered by PV Tech's Head of Research, Dr Finlay Colville at the PV ModuleTech conference in Napa on 15 June 2022: - The PV industry has moved beyond its legacy supply/demand dynamics: why has this happened? - ASPs can’t go down globally in the near to mid-term: why is this the case? - Is there new capacity coming to the rescue? - Has China’s polysilicon industry become a new PV pricing cartel? - Making products & deploying domestically in a TW annual landscape: how can the U.S. really do this in practice? - The real PV technology roadmap: why do only 2% of producers matter today?
4 October 2022
Solar & Storage Finance USA, the only event that connects developers to capital and capital to solar and storage projects, will be back in November 2022.

Read Next

July 6, 2022
US power distribution company Entergy Arkansas has issued a request for proposals (RfP) for 1GW of solar and wind resources.
July 6, 2022
US PV developer Birch Creek Development has increased its existing credit facility with debt financing provider Fundamental Renewables to US$250 million to pursue its 5GW solar pipeline in the US and support its module procurement strategy.
July 5, 2022
Total Eren has commissioned a 131MWp solar project in Uzbekistan, the independent power producer’s first to exclusively use bifacial modules.
July 1, 2022
The US Supreme Court has restricted the federal government’s authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from power plants in a ruling that critics have warned will hit renewables deployment and hobble the Biden administration’s climate agenda.
PV Tech Premium
July 1, 2022
PV Tech Premium spoke with Cypress Creek Renewable Energy and AES Clean Energy to discuss the newly formed US Solar Buyer Consortium, its objectives, market challenges and the potential advantages it holds for US manufacturing and project development.
PV Tech Premium
June 30, 2022
US authorities’ move to require documentation showing the source of quartzite in solar module imports should come as no surprise, experts have said, amid suggestions most companies will be able to overcome the latest hurdle that threatens to delay shipments.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Upcoming Webinars
July 19, 2022
Free Webinar - 10am and 6pm BST
Upcoming Webinars
July 27, 2022
9am (UTC +2) / 3pm (UTC +8)
Solar Media Events
October 4, 2022
New York, USA