Arizona solar industry hinges on imminent grandfathering decision

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email
The imminent decision of the Corporation Commission will dictate whether customers with pending solar applications will also be entitled to grandfathering. Source: Flickr/Stefan Thiesen

The Arizona Corporation Commission (ACC) will decide either Tuesday or Wednesday whether to amend its recent decision on grandfathering, to alter the timing when consumers will be grandfathered under pre-existing rules. The decision will have a significant impact on the future of solar in the state.

Late last month, net metering in the state was effectively eliminated after regulators voted to replace retail net metering with a wholesale rate.

The new export rate will be based initially on the cost of energy from utility-scale solar providers, which will be much lower than the retail rate – averaging around six cents/kWh compared to around 11.5 cents/kWh.

At the time of the decision, many industry commentators claimed this decision had the potential to significantly curtail solar progress in the state; lessening demand for PV systems due to the lower rate of credit for excess solar energy production.

Despite criticism, the ACC defended its 4-1 decision saying that it was “good for solar in Arizona” as it made solar “fairer because all customers will begin to share more appropriately in the cost of the electrical grid”. This argument is linked to the long-debated sentiment that non-solar users often pay for solar customers’ use of the grid.

Solar advocates rebutted at the time that wholesale rates do not reflect the true value of solar and its accompanying economic and environmental benefits. They also countered that the ending of retail net metering would considerably hamper the industry. 


The new rates were to only apply to customers whose solar systems were connected to the grid after to the decision. On the other hand, customers who were connected before the decision would be grandfathered for 20 years from the date of interconnection.

In a rare case of a utility siding with solar advocates, APS appealed to regulators urging the ACC to amend its decision and consider full grandfathering for solar customers, including pending applications are also grandfathered in.

“Otherwise, whether a customer is grandfathered could be determined not by when a customer makes a decision to submit an application to interconnect, but instead by the volume of (rooftop solar) applications received, among other factors outside a customer’s control,” APS said, according to the Daily Star.

A recommendation supported by APS, fellow utility Tucson Electric Power and a host of solar supports suggests that language in the ruling should be edited to include customers with pending applications and not exclusively apply to those already connected.

Jason Johns, an energy and utilities partner at law firm Stoel Rives told PV Tech that such language clarifications are critical:

“By clarifying that customers who have requested interconnection service will be grandfathered, as opposed to drawing the line at customers who have received that service, the ACC will likely cause more customers to be grandfathered into the previous formulation of APS’s NEM programme – a benefit to those who prefer the previous NEM formulation. 

“The benefit of the clarification for both customers and APS is that it provides customers with more control over whether they are grandfathered and consequently also reduces the likelihood that APS is blamed for a customer failing to be grandfathered.”

In response to the APS request and subsequently garnered support, the ACC will decide either today or tomorrow in its public meeting whether to reconsider and alter the grandfathering provisions in the new rate design. 

Read Next

September 23, 2021
Arizonan utility Salt River Project (SRP) and renewables company Clēnera have signed a 20-year power purchase agreement (PPA) for the CO Bar Solar project that is expected to deliver between 440-480MW of power
September 21, 2021
India added 521MW of rooftop solar in Q2 2021, an increase of 517% compared to the 85MW added in the same quarter last year despite a slight increase in costs, according to a Mercom India report.
PV Tech Premium
September 17, 2021
PV Tech spoke to investors and analysts about why Brazil is fast becoming an attractive market for solar investment.
PV Tech Premium
September 13, 2021
Following the release of the US Department’s Solar Futures Study, Liam Stoker assesses the downstream and upstream trends that must be realised for US solar to fulfil its potential.
September 6, 2021
A coalition of 347 organisations has warned that potential changes to California's policy support for rooftop solar could set back climate change progress and harm low-income access to solar energy.
PV Tech Premium
September 3, 2021
For years California, Texas and Florida have dominated the US solar market, but backed by the investment tax credit, strong state-specific renewables standards and falling costs, new states are coming to the fore. Molly Lempriere takes a look at what is driving them, and the hurdles they face if they are to challenge the ‘Big Three’.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
October 6, 2021
Solar Media Events, Upcoming Webinars
October 6, 2021
Solar Media Events
October 19, 2021
Solar Media Events
December 1, 2021