Utilities slam proposed Texas laws that would shift ‘significant’ costs onto solar projects

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email
Duke Energy’s 200MW Holstein solar project in Texas came online last year. Image: Duke Energy.

Three US utilities have hit out at proposed changes to Texas’s energy market that they say would lead to new costs for solar facilities and curb investment in the state’s renewables sector.

In a letter sent this week to Texas Governor Greg Abbott and other lawmakers, the renewables subsidiaries of NextEra Energy, Duke Energy and Southern Company raised “serious concerns” about the legislation that relates to the provision of ancillary services in Texas.

Having invested almost US$15 billion in clean energy assets in the state with the confidence in its stable business environment, the utilities said enactment of the new laws would erode trust and impose “onerous new cost burdens”.

“These bills would unfairly and unjustifiably shift significant costs onto wind and solar facilities in the State of Texas, penalising existing assets and discouraging future investment,” the companies said in the letter.

One of the bills would require the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) to directly assign to solar and wind projects the costs of ancillary services that it incurs to address renewables-related reliability issues. Another bill would mandate the Public Utility Commission of Texas to require intermittent resources to purchase ancillary services and replacement power to manage net load variability.

The development follows a winter storm in February that overwhelmed Texas’s electricity infrastructure and left millions without power, with more than 51GW of generation capacity offline at one point.

According to Jeff Clark, president of trade association Advanced Power Alliance, anti-renewables groups “are now taking advantage of the February winter crisis to harm the economics of renewable investment to prop up fossil fuel generation”. He recently said: “Imposing additional costs on renewable generation does nothing to address failures related to the winter storm.”

Concerns about the laws have also been raised by the Partnership for Renewable Energy Finance (PREF), an affiliation of companies that invest in clean energy, including Enel, BlackRock, General Electric and Google. A recent letter sent by PREF to Texas lawmakers said the measures would “inappropriately and unfairly shift the cost” of ancillary services onto renewable energy generators rather than all the beneficiaries of those ancillary services.

Having invested tens of billions of dollars in Texas partly because of confidence in its friendly business environment, the letter said trust would be undermined by the proposed legislation that would “erode confidence that the state will continue to provide the financial stability necessary for future energy investment”.

Read Next

September 27, 2021
Solar developer 174 Power Global and oil and gas company TotalEnergies have started construction of an 80MW behind-the-meter PV project in Texas.
September 14, 2021
The Senate of Illinois has passed legislation that will commit the US state to reaching 50% renewables by 2040 and 100% carbon-free electricity by 2045.
PV Tech Premium
September 13, 2021
Following the release of the US Department’s Solar Futures Study, Liam Stoker assesses the downstream and upstream trends that must be realised for US solar to fulfil its potential.
September 6, 2021
A coalition of 347 organisations has warned that potential changes to California's policy support for rooftop solar could set back climate change progress and harm low-income access to solar energy.
September 2, 2021
A round-up of the latest news from the US solar market, including developments from Invenergy, SB Energy and RWE Renewables.
September 1, 2021
Vietnam officials have teased new details of a scheme designed to replace the country’s successful solar feed-in tariff (FiT) policy.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
October 19, 2021
Upcoming Webinars
November 10, 2021
8am (PST) | 5pm (CET)
Solar Media Events
December 1, 2021