Uncertainty lingers over ‘Change in Law’ clarification for Indian solar

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on reddit
Share on email
Credit: Getty

India’s Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE) has issued a clarification in its guidelines for tariff-based competitive solar procurement implying that a change in duties will henceforth be covered as a ‘Change in Law’, which would give developers protection in case a safeguard, anti-dumping or any other duty is imposed.

Vinay Rustagi, managing director of consultancy firm Bridge to India, told PV Tech that the clarification is desirable in general and would bring welcome long-term comfort to the private sector, but it still leaves uncertainty around many of the tenders that have already been issued, which currently represents more than 11.7GW.

While the sector has heard several times from power minister R.K. Singh and MNRE officials that PV projects already bid out or tendered would be exempt from the looming threat of anti-dumping or safeguard duties should they be brought in, the industry has been desperately waiting for confirmation in writing.

The new clarification cited Clause 5.7.2 in the guidelines, which describes any change in the rates of any taxes, which have a direct effect on a project, as a ‘Change in Law’.

It said that in order to bring more clarity and remove uncertainty, the term 'change in the rates of any taxes' in that Clause includes ‘change in rates of taxes, duties and cess’.

This means that in the case of a change in duties, the solar power generator or procurer shall be entitled to compensation by the other party.

However, Rustagi said: “The problem is that it doesn't do anything in the immediate run, because we have huge uncertainty about safeguard duty. In such a scenario, if the risk is passed on to DISCOMs, they will simply not go ahead with the tenders as is already happening right now. Even if they accept this risk, the ongoing tenders would have to be either amended or re-issued with these revised provisions again causing massive delays to the process. It is really not clear in terms of which of the procurement agencies, SECI or state-level will actually take these guidelines on board and issue clarifications before any further auctions are held. So the long-term clarity is good but short-term immediate clarity is still not available.”

He said the position of projects bid out before the announcement of duties is still unclear – adding: “That is something which the market needs much more desperately right now.”

Furthermore, the guidelines state that compensation from the ‘Change in Law’ would be determined and made effective from a date decided by the appropriate Commission.

Rustagi said: “Change-in-law provisions are always very tricky, as even though the risk may be passed in theory to the Discoms, but the amount of compensation has to be determined by the respective regulator and that process in itself – in terms of what is the actual impact and what is the amount of compensation to be payable to the developer – that process can be very lengthy and complex.

“So yes, from a principle point of view, it’s good to have this clarity, but again operationally and procedurally it will still be a challenge for the developers.”

Uncertainty around the threat of duties issue has seen tenders held up and even an uptick in utility-scale solar tariffs. Last week, Gujarat, which has high irradiation and whose Discom has the highest credit rating in India, saw winning tariffs hover around three rupees per unit, around INR0.35-0.40/kWh higher than the last tender issued by the same authority, GUVNL, last year. 

The original anti-dumping petition has been terminated, but a new one is expected to be filed by the petitioners, the Indian Solar Manufacturing Association (ISMA), while the threat of a Safeguard Duty still looms.

Read Next

PV Tech Premium
May 25, 2022
Solar EPC Sterling and Wilson believes an easing of PV module supply concerns, the rise of alternate supply chains and a gigawatt-scale green hydrogen market will drive both short- and medium-term growth for PV developers and EPCs.
May 25, 2022
Module price increases, higher raw material costs and logistical challenges will pull down the return on equity (ROE) for 25GW of India solar projects, with 5GW of those at high risk given when they submitted their bids.
May 9, 2022
Indian independent power producer (IPP) Azure Power has appointed Harsh Shah as CEO, effective from 1 July, following the resignation of its previous CEO, Ranjit Gupta, last month.
May 6, 2022
Tata Power Solar has landed what it claims to be India’s largest single solar EPC order of 1GW for roughly INR5500 crore (US$715 million) from Indian state-owned utility SJVN Ltd.
May 2, 2022
Private equity firm Actis has agreed to sell its Sprng Energy renewables platform to energy major Shell for US$1.55 billion.
May 2, 2022
Indian Independent power producer (IPP) ReNew Power has signed a number of offtake agreements with both state utilities and corporates in India totalling roughly 2GW.

Subscribe to Newsletter

Upcoming Events

Solar Media Events
June 7, 2022
Leonardo Royal London City, London, UK
Solar Media Events
June 14, 2022
Napa, USA
Solar Media Events
June 22, 2022
Sheraton Austin Hotel at the Capitol, Austin, Texas